Mendel's principles of heredity: A defenceMendel, Gregor
Science
Mendel's principles of heredity: A defence
Mendel, Gregor
Heredity; Hybridization; Mendel's law; Weldon, Walter Frank Raphael. Mendel's laws of alternative inheritance in peas
Nevertheless a definite assumption is implicitly made regarding the
gametes. It is not in question that differences between these gametes
may occur in respect of the heritage they bear; yet it is assumed
that these differences will be distributed among the gametes of any
individual zygote in such a way that each gamete remains capable,
on fertilisation, of transmitting _all_ the characters (both of the
parent-zygote and of its progenitors) to the zygote which it then
contributes to form (and to the posterity of that zygote) in the
intensity indicated by the law. Hence the gametes of any individual
are taken as collectively a fair sample of all the racial characters
in their appropriate intensities, and this theory demands that there
shall have been no qualitative redistribution of characters among the
gametes of any zygote in such a way that some gametes shall be finally
excluded from partaking of and transmitting any specific part of
the heritage. The theory further demands--and by the analogy of what
we know otherwise not only of animals and plants, but of physical or
chemical laws, perhaps this is the most serious assumption of all--that
the structure of the gametes shall admit of their being capable of
transmitting any character in any intensity varying from zero to
totality with equal ease; and that gametes of each intensity are all
equally likely to occur, given a pedigree of appropriate arithmetical
composition.
Such an assumption appears so improbable that even in cases where
the facts seem as yet to point to this conclusion with exceptional
clearness, as in the case of human stature, I cannot but feel there is
still room for reserve of judgment.
However this may be, the Law of Ancestral Heredity, and all
modifications of it yet proposed, falls short in the respect specified
above, that _it does not directly attempt to give any account of the
distribution of the heritage among the gametes_ of any one individual.
Mendel’s conception differs fundamentally from that involved in the Law
of Ancestral Heredity. The relation of his hypothesis to the foregoing
may be most easily shown if we consider it first in application to the
phenomena resulting from the cross-breeding of two pure varieties.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account