Mental diseases: a public health problemMay, James Vance
Science
Mental diseases: a public health problem
May, James Vance
Mental health services; Psychology, Pathological
1913 47.0 per cent 22.5 per cent
1914 46.7 " " 25.2 " "
1915 47.0 " " 26.4 " "
1916 48.5 " " 27.8 " "
1917 47.8 " " 27.1 " "
1918 46.4 " " 27.5 " "
1919 46.8 " " 26.4 " "
1920 45.3 " " 24.8 " "
The percentage of the foreign born as shown by the first admissions to
the Massachusetts state hospitals during the last eleven years was as
follows:—
1910 44.88 per cent
1911 44.65 " "
1912 44.40 " "
1913 45.30 " "
1914 45.75 " "
1915 45.59 " "
1916 43.87 " "
1917 43.40 " "
1918 43.07 " "
1919 43.38 " "
1920 42.18 " "
The percentage of aliens as shown by the first admissions to
Massachusetts hospitals was 26.40 per cent in 1918, 27.54 in 1919 and
22.73 per cent in 1920.
Studies of the population of the New York state hospitals show that the
aliens have for a period of several years constituted nearly thirty per
cent of the entire number. The influence which immigration may have
had in determining the relative frequency of various psychoses in our
institutions is an exceedingly interesting question. In speaking of the
susceptibility of certain races to special types of disease, Salmon[74]
says, "This is particularly true of mental diseases, for if racial
characteristics profoundly affect political, social and religious
ideals we must look for a similar influence upon the individual makeup
which so largely determines trends in mental disease. All those who are
familiar with mental diseases among the Japanese in California testify
to the remarkable tendency to suicide in that race, not only in
depressed conditions but in conditions in which suicidal tendencies, in
other races, are not frequent. This is in accordance with the general
attitude of the Japanese toward self-destruction. The strong tendency
to delusional trends of a persecutory nature in West Indian negroes,
the frequency with which we find hidden sexual complexes among the
Hebrews and the remarkable prevalence of mutism among Poles, even
in psychoses in which mutism is not a common symptom, are familiar
examples of the influence of racial traits upon mental diseases."
As the result of a special study of this subject Salmon has reached
the following conclusions: "1. The psychoses more prevalent among
Hebrews than in the native stock are manic depressive psychosis,
dementia praecox, the psychoneuroses, and psychoses associated with
constitutional inferiority. 2. The absence of alcoholic psychoses
among Hebrews is the most striking clinical fact in connection with
immigration. In 1909 there were but 3 patients with alcoholic psychoses
in 448 Hebrews admitted to all the New York state hospitals. 3. The
very high prevalence of general paresis among Italians bears a direct
relation to the high prevalence of venereal diseases among Italians in
New York....
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account