Mental diseases: a public health problemMay, James Vance
Science
Mental diseases: a public health problem
May, James Vance
Mental health services; Psychology, Pathological
"14. That we are in favor of any legislation that will secure a
definite standard of qualification for medical men giving expert
testimony."
An equal amount of consideration has been given to this important
question from time to time by the American Institute of Criminal Law
and Criminology. At a recent meeting of that organization the following
recommendations were submitted by a committee:
"1. That in all cases of felony or misdemeanor punishable by a prison
sentence the question of responsibility be not submitted to the jury,
which will thus be called upon to determine only that the offense was
committed by the defendant.
"2. That the disposition and treatment (including punishment) of all
such misdemeanants and felons, i.e., the sentence imposed, be based
upon a study of the individual offender by properly qualified and
impartial experts cooperating with the courts.
"3. That provisions be made permitting the transfer of such
misdemeanants and felons at any time after conviction from one
institution to another affording a different kind of treatment upon the
presentation of evidence of the needs for such action satisfactory to
the court which passed sentence.
"4. That no maximum term be set to any sentence.
"5. That no parole or probation be granted without suitable psychiatric
examination.
"6. That in considering applications for pardons and commutation
careful attention be given to reports of qualified experts showing
the applicant's mental age and mental stability and that in drafting
statutes determining or defining juvenile delinquency, mental age
and mental stability, within reasonable limits, be regarded as of
importance with the calendar age of the delinquent.
"In view of the foregoing and as an initial step towards the ends
stated, the committee submits the following resolution and urges its
immediate adoption:
"Resolved, That the several states be urged to make provision for
the psychiatric examination, under conditions permitting prolonged
observation when necessary, of all persons convicted of a felony,
misdemeanor or other offense by properly qualified experts appointed
to assist the court in reaching a decision as to the proper disposition
and treatment of the offender."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account