Mental diseases: a public health problemMay, James Vance
Science
Mental diseases: a public health problem
May, James Vance
Mental health services; Psychology, Pathological
Our knowledge of the psychoses accompanying paralysis agitans is very
inadequate. The disease was first fully described by Parkinson in an
English publication in 1817, although, according to Camp, similar
cases were reported by Schwarz in 1766. The etiology of this condition
is unknown and the pathology is not at all definite. It seems to be
the rather general opinion of neurologists that mental disturbances
are quite rare in Parkinson's Disease. Camp,[199] for instance, has
the following to say on this subject:—"Mental conditions have also
been described, but usually the patient's mind is entirely clear. In
the very old the changes incident to senility, such as irritability,
childishness, etc., insomnia and memory changes, might be expected and
may require special treatment. Often these patients are emotionally
unstable and spells of forced weeping or laughter occur." Krafft-Ebing
refers to mental weakness in paralysis agitans and speaks of the
frequency of melancholia with hallucinations and suicidal impulses
occurring intermittently and appearing with exacerbations of the
disease. He speaks of premature senility as playing the most important
etiological rôle. McCarthy[200] expresses the opinion that: "Beyond
a tendency on the part of some patients to adopt a whining and
complaining manner, the mind remains very clear; in fact, the good
nature and complaisance of most of the patients, in spite of the
severity of the symptoms, is a matter of common observation. Dementia
may, however, complicate a case of the disease." On the other hand,
Parant, a French writer who made an elaborate study of this subject in
1883, described three distinct varieties of mental disturbance observed
by him. In the milder cases he found changes in the personality.
This is shown by irritability, egotism, restlessness, suspicion,
undue sensitiveness regarding their disease, mild persecutory ideas,
tendencies to depression, indifference and apathy. The second class
of cases described included mental deterioration with difficulty
of thought, loss of memory, etc. The third group includes definite
psychoses characterized generally by depressions with or without
hallucinations and delusions. Hallucinations of sight are said to be
common. Delusions of persecution are prominent and hypochondriacal
and somatic ideas frequently occur. Suicidal tendencies are very
pronounced. According to Ball, these episodes come and go "with the
aggravation of the sensory symptoms, and they seem to disappear when
the tremor decreases or ceases entirely." The usual tendency in these
cases, as shown by Parant, is to terminate in complete deterioration.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account