Mental diseases: a public health problem — John Shaqi
Mental diseases: a public health problemMay, James Vance
Science
Mental diseases: a public health problem
May, James Vance
Mental health services; Psychology, Pathological
The experience of the past has shown that the injection of politics
into the administration of state institutions is almost invariably
due to the over-centralization of power in state departments, the
local boards of trustees or managers either being abolished or largely
deprived of their authority. The greatest menace to the future welfare
of the hospitals for mental diseases is, in the opinion of many, the
unfortunate result of a popular and more or less legitimate demand for
the reorganization of state governments, reducing their administrative
activities to a few separate departments, each one under the entire
charge of a director responsible only to the Governor. The argument
for this procedure is that it does away with innumerable commissions,
boards and departments working along independent lines without any
reference to the desirability of coordinating the activities of the
state as a whole and places the affairs of the commonwealth on an
efficient, systematic and economical basis. There is no question as to
the theoretical advisability of such methods. The difficulty is, that
in putting into practical operation this unquestionably commendable
undertaking, the humanitarian aspect of the charitable enterprises
conducted by state governments for more than a century, is likely to
be lost sight of. It is almost invariably urged that the directors
of these various departments should be experienced business men of
recognized ability and that in only such a way can the affairs of the
state be put on a "businesslike basis." It must be confessed that
this argument is one which appeals very strongly to the taxpayer,
who naturally has not given the matter very careful thought. There
are other important considerations, however, where the question of
administering hospitals is involved. As Commissioner Kline[26] has
said:—"If it be conceded that the care and treatment of the mentally
sick is a highly specialized medical problem, requiring the services
of medical experts, and that the institutions function primarily
for the welfare of the patient, then the supervision and control of
institutions should be in the hands of medical men especially trained
for the purpose."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account