Mental diseases: a public health problemMay, James Vance
Science
Mental diseases: a public health problem
May, James Vance
Mental health services; Psychology, Pathological
Southard has raised the question as to the correct designation of
institutions of the psychopathic hospital type:—"A word is again
necessary as to the meaning of the term 'psychopathic hospital.'
For various reasons the term has become so attractive in propaganda
that a comparatively large number of institutions of whatever scope
have been founded or recommended to receive the term 'psychopathic
hospital,' 'institute,' 'department' or 'ward.' Thus there is
developing a tendency in state hospitals to denominate the receiving
ward 'psychopathic.' There can be no advantage in this designation
other than that of calling old ideas by new names. The idea of the
receiving ward for committed cases destined to receive the ordinary
probate court group of cases is not altered or improved in any manner
by the designation 'psychopathic.' The best opinion seems to be that
a psychopathic hospital or institute shall be an institution in which
all types of mental cases, from the probate court group on the one hand
up to the most dubious and difficult cases of mental disorder on the
other, may be examined; but if an institution is primarily or chiefly
concerned with patients of the medicolegal, committable or custodial
group, to serve merely as a vestibule through which committed cases
pass, such an institution has by no means the broad scope which the
very general term 'psychopathic' implies. The institution is not a
modified or sublimated form of receiving ward for a great district
hospital."
There is, of course, no reason why the reception service of an ordinary
state hospital should be spoken of as constituting a psychopathic ward.
This accomplishes nothing more, perhaps, than to raise some question
as to what the functions of the rest of the institution may be. The
designation psychopathic hospital has been rather loosely used and
is, as Southard has definitely shown, of American origin. It has been
applied somewhat indiscriminately from time to time to practically
every form of activity related to the care and treatment of mental
diseases outside of the generally recognized state hospital field.
These may be summarized as follows:—
1. Detention wards, pavilions, etc. Intended for no purpose other than
the custody of the "insane" pending commitment.
2. Psychiatric wards of general hospitals—such as Pavilion F in
Albany. There would appear to be no reason for the use of the word
psychopathic in such cases, the term psychiatric being much more
clearly applicable.
3. Institutes designed primarily for research only or for research and
instruction, with or without clinical facilities.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account