Mexican letters written during the progress of the late war between the United States and Mexico, no. 1.Brackenridge, H. M. (Henry Marie)
History
Mexican letters written during the progress of the late war between the United States and Mexico, no. 1.
Brackenridge, H. M. (Henry Marie)
Mexican War, 1846-1848; United States -- Politics and government -- 1845-1849
Suppose the laws of Mexico _prohibit_ slavery, would the simple
repeal of the laws _establish_ it? I do not see by what
reasoning it would do so. Is it probable, I would almost say
possible, that slavery will be introduced by positive enactment?
This would not only be local legislation, and on that account
objectionable, even if it were possible, _as Congress is at
present constituted_. It is said to be carried there by the
Constitution. How can this be, if the Constitution does not
extend there? A part cannot be extended without extending the
whole. Congress is forbidden by the Constitution to legislate on
certain subjects. This is true, but it is a limitation on its
own powers, the effects of which are felt by the territories, as
well as the States, but is no argument to prove, that the
Constitution extends to the former as well as to the latter. I
cannot see by what reasoning the Constitution is extended to
them, and yet, I can readily see many curious, inconvenient, and
unjust consequences arising from this view of the subject. It is
impossible to avoid such consequences, when we attempt to reason
from false premises. We have started wrong in acquiring
territory, when such acquisition was not contemplated by the
Constitution; and that error is the cause of other errors. I see
no way of surmounting these difficulties, but by mutual
forbearance, reciprocal respect for each others feelings and
interests.[11]
Footnote 11:
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account