Little need be said of the actual constituents of the volume, which
has however perhaps lost something of its intended 'composition',
in the artistic sense, by losing its tail. A good English edition
of Cleveland has long been wanted: and I think--the thought being
stripped of presumption by the number and valiancy of my helpers--that
we have at last given one. Stanley and King--truer poets than
Cleveland, if less interesting to the general public--also called for
fresh presentation. If anybody demurs to Flatman and still more to
Whiting he must be left to his own opinion. I shall only note here
that on Cleveland I was guilty of injustice to the Library of the
University of Edinburgh (to which I owe much) by saying that
it contained no edition of this reviler of Caledonia. None was
discoverable in my time, the process of overhauling and re-cataloguing
being then incomplete. But my friend and successor, Professor
Grierson, tells me that one has since been found. As to King, I have
recently seen doubts cast on his authorship of 'Tell me no more'. But
I have seen no valid reasons alleged for them, and I do not know of
any one else who has the slightest claim to it.
Of the whole three volumes it is still less necessary to say much. I
have owed special thanks in succession to Mr. Doble, Mr. Milford,
and Mr. Chapman (now Secretary) of the Clarendon Press; to Professors
Firth and Case (indeed, but for the former's generous imparting of
his treasures the whole thing could hardly have been done) for loan
of books as well as answering of questions; and to not a few others,
among whom I may specially mention my friend of many years, the Rev.
William Hunt, D.Litt., Honorary Fellow of Trinity College, Oxford. I
wish the work had done greater credit to all this assistance and to
the generous expenditure of the University and its Press. But such
as it is I can say (speaking no doubt as a fool) that I should myself
have been exceedingly grateful if somebody had done it fifty years
ago: and that I shall be satisfied if only a few people are grateful
for it between now and fifty or five hundred years hence. For there is
stuff in it, though not mine, which will keep as long as the longest
of these periods and longer.[1]
GEORGE SAINTSBURY.
1 _Royal Crescent, Bath.
Oak-Apple Day, 1921_.
[Footnote 1: The tolerably gentle reader will easily understand
that, in a book written, and even printed, at considerable
intervals of time, Time itself will sometimes have affected
statements. There may be a few such cases here. But it seems
unnecessary to burden the thing with possible Corrigenda, as to
the post-war price of the Cross-bath (p. 360), &c.]
CONTENTS
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account