Miscellaneous Pieces, in ProseBarbauld, Mrs. (Anna Letitia)
General
Miscellaneous Pieces, in Prose
Barbauld, Mrs. (Anna Letitia)
English prose literature -- 18th century
A love of what is uncommon and out of the way
has often occasioned such extravagance in the representation of these
characters as to disgust from their want of probability; but, where a
due moderation is observed, and the peculiarities, though unusual, are
such as really exist in nature, great entertainment may be derived
from their exhibition. Of this kind are the admirable _Misanthrope_ and
_Malade Imaginaire_ of Moliere; and the _Old Bachelor_ and _Sir Sampson
Legend_ of Congreve.
From hence it appears but a small gradation to the exhibition of
individuals upon the stage; and yet the difference is important and
essential. That which marks out the distinction between individuals
of the same species is something entirely uncommunicable; therefore
the rational end of Comedy, which is the reformation of folly, cannot
take place in personal ridicule; for it will not be alledged that
reforming the person himself is the object. Nor can it scarcely ever
be just to expose an individual to the ridicule of the stage; since
folly, and not vice, being the proper subject of that ridicule, it is
hardly possible any one can deserve so severe a punishment. Indeed
the exposing of folly can scarcely be the plea; for all the common, or
even the rarer kinds of folly lie open to the attack of Comedy under
fictitious characters, by means of which the failing may be ridiculed
without the person. Personal ridicule must therefore turn, as we find
it always has done, upon bodily imperfections, awkward habits, and
uncouth gestures; which the low arts of mimickry inhumanly drag forth
to public view, for the mean purpose of exciting present merriment. In
the best hands, personal Comedy would be a degradation of the stage,
and an unwarrantable severity; but in the hands it would be likely, if
encouraged, to fall into, it would prove an intolerable nuisance. I
should therefore, without hesitation, join those who utterly condemn
this species of comic ridicule. It is also to be considered, that the
author shews his talents to disadvantage, and cannot lay any basis of
future fame, in this walk. For the resemblance which depends so much
upon mimickry is lost upon those of the audience who are not acquainted
with the original, and upon every one who only reads the piece. Mr.
Foote’s works will aptly exemplify this matter; in which the fund of
genuine Comedy, derived from happy strokes upon the manners of the
times, and uncommon, but not entirely singular characters, will secure
a lasting admiration, when the mimickry which supported the parts of
_Squintum_ and _Cadwallader_ is despised or forgotten.
Having thus attempted to trace the different sources of what I
conceive the essential part of true Comedy, the _ridicule derived from
character_, it remains to say somewhat of the mixture of additional
matter which it has received as a composition.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account