Kant’s view on care and discipline, in its general character and
details, very much reminds us of that of Locke. Kant is peculiarly
empirical here in his procedure, and his protest against playing with
and flattering the child, against indiscriminate punishment, his plea
for the freedom of children’s bodily activities, for early inculcation
of self-restraint and obedience, for gaining the child’s confidence and
respect, his opinion in regard to manners, and children’s crying, his
advocation of the hardening process, all seem to be the repetitions of
Locke in a modified language. In regard to habit formation, the two
writers seem to differ from each other, for Kant repeatedly opposes
the formation or fostering of any habits in children. He says: “The
more habits a man allows himself to form, the less free and independent
he becomes; ... for whatever he has been accustomed to early in life
always retains a certain attraction for him in after-life” (2: p.
45). But if we read his lines a little more carefully we find this
opposition more apparent than real. One emphasizes the establishing
of good habits while the other lays stress on the prevention of the
formation of harmful habits. Whether Kant ever read Locke’s “Thoughts
on Education,” and was thus influenced by him or not, I am unable to
ascertain. This great similarity may come from their common experience
in tutorship. Or we might attribute it largely to the influence he
received from Rousseau and Basedow, and not directly to that of Locke.
Care and discipline were in Kant’s view essentially negative functions.
The positive side of education he calls culture. It includes the
physical, mental, and moral training. It is the building up or the
unfolding of naturally endowed faculties of man by their exercise.
Instruction is sometimes necessary, but it is only as an aid to the
self-activity of the child. Children should be provided with ample
opportunities for such exercise.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account