Modern Musical DriftHenderson, W. J. (William James)
History
Modern Musical Drift
Henderson, W. J. (William James)
Music -- History and criticism; Strauss, Richard, 1864-1949; Wagner, Richard, 1813-1883
The sacred spear has some connection with the story, but the weapon
is not an important feature of Christianity. There is even room for
doubt as to whether there ever was a sacred spear at all. The wound
certainly existed; but who can vouch for the preservation of the
spear as an object of reverence? So let us for the present dismiss
the profound religious basis of Richard Wagner's "Parsifal." Buddha
and Arthur Schopenhauer taught the dramatist more essentials than the
Holy Bible did. The foundations of the drama rest on the philosophy
of negation. The Christianity is merely ornamental, spectacular, and
delusive.
III.--THE NATIONAL RELIGIOUS DRAMA
I shall lay down a type of theological orthodoxy to which all
the divine legends in our city must conform.
PLATO, _Republic_ (_Grote's abstract_).
"Parsifal" is the supreme test of the outcome of Wagner's theory
that the modern theatre ought to bear the same relation to the life
of the people as the theatre of the Greeks did. All students of the
master's writings know that he preached this especially in those
years when his system had attained definite and detailed form in
his mind. In the Greek theatre he saw an art influence far-reaching
and mighty,--an influence which dominated because it dramatized the
artistic and religious ideals of a people. That he failed to discern
the identity of religion and art in the symbolical embodiments named
gods by the imaginative Greeks is another story.
Furthermore, he objected strenuously and rightly to any criticism of
his philosophic and artistic system based on the study of his early
works, which were written before his system was fully developed. In
the "Communication to My Friends" he says:--
"Certain critics who pretend to judge my art doings as a
connected whole have set about their task with this same
uncritical heedlessness and lack of feeling. Views on the
nature of art that I have proclaimed from a standpoint which
it took me years of evolution step by step to gain, they
seize on for the standard of their verdict, and point them
back upon those very compositions from which I started on the
natural path of evolution that led me to this standpoint.
"When for instance--not from the standpoint of abstract
æsthetics, but from that of practical artistic experience--I
denote the _Christian principle as hostile to or incapable of
art_, these critics point me out the contradiction in which
I stand toward my earlier dramatic works, which undoubtedly
are filled with a certain tincture of this principle so
inextricably blended with our modern evolution."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account