Poets, Spanish; Spanish poetry -- History and criticism; Spanish poetry -- Translations into English
It is fortunate for any writer to have his works sent forth to the
world in any language of more than usual ascendency, such as the Latin
or English, whereby to obtain for himself, if he can claim it, the
most extended reputation. But it is more fortunate for a translator
under similar circumstances, because languages of such a character
are almost of necessity mixed languages, acquiring from that cause
an extraordinary nerve and richness, which render translations into
them to be made more easily and satisfactorily than from them into a
poorer. The English is essentially suited for such a purpose, as, being
compounded of the French and German languages, it becomes a double
one, combining the nerve of the one with the facility of expression
of the other, and the copiousness arising from the union of both. The
Latin is still more a mixed language, the roots of which are yet to
be developed, notwithstanding all the labours of philologists, who
have erred in wandering after imaginary extinct languages for its
derivations, instead of looking into those yet existing. Considering
the Spanish to be the direct descendant of the Latin, it may be a
matter of surprise that, though a very sonorous language, it cannot
be termed a rich one. Abounding in long words (sesquipedalia verba),
it loses in precision and strength what is gained in sound, and
thus the ideas are encumbered when simplification was required. The
comparatively monosyllabic character of the English language has in
this respect an immense advantage for the translator, as it enables him
to give the sentiments of the original more concisely than one from
it into another. Having also more synonyms with different shades of
meaning, a greater precision may be lost or gained, according to the
circumstances and the judgement applied to them. Thus a translation
may sometimes be even superior to the original, from its giving the
ideas more distinctly, and as it is the test of good writing to find
how it reads in another language, so with really superior authors it
may be a matter of little importance in what version their thoughts are
expressed. “Words are the daughters of earth, but thoughts are the sons
of heaven.” It is not presumed hereby that the following translations
all come under this consideration, but with the advantages above
expressed, it may be hoped that, as exotics in a greenhouse, these
flowers of Spanish poetry may be found pleasing representations of what
they were in their native soil, even if they cannot be made entirely
denizens of our own.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account