Modern shipbuilding and the men engaged in itPollock, David
History
Modern shipbuilding and the men engaged in it
Pollock, David
Shipbuilding -- Great Britain
The extended employment of machinery has given impetus to, and
received impetus from, the system of “piece-work” now so much in
vogue in shipyards. In several of the operations, such as riveting
and smithing, the nature of the work peculiarly lends itself to the
system, and piece-work has consequently been in force, as regards
these operations, for many years. In several other departments,
however, such as plate and bar fitting, joinery, and carpentry,
piece-work is only contemporaneous with and largely the consequence
of improved modern machinery. Reference to “piece-work” here is not
made with the intention of discussing its effects on the labour
question—concerned as this is with such large issues—but simply
of showing what effect the system has had on the character of
shipyard workmanship. It was a favourite argument some years ago,
when piece-work was being rapidly extended, that the system was bad
because it would lead to and foster scamp-work and bad workmanship.
The results of the past dozen years’ experience disprove this
completely, and for reasons which, as early as 1877, were pointed out
by Mr William Denny—to whose spirited advocacy and adoption of the
system its present degree of acceptance with workmen is in no small
measure owing. In his admirably written pamphlet on “The Worth of
Wages,” published in the year named, Mr Denny says:—
“As to piece-work leading to bad workmanship, this would certainly
be the result were no special arrangements made to prevent it.
These special arrangements include a rigid system of inspecting
the work, and the rejection, at the workman’s cost, of all bad
and inferior work. There is no difficulty in carrying out such
a system, for foremen, freed from the necessity of watching the
quantity of the work—which is looked after by a special clerk—and
of checking the laziness of their men, can give their whole
attention to the matter of quality. In fact, piece-work compels
so thorough an inspection, that we find the work done under it in
our iron department much superior to what used to be done some
years ago on time. It is very curious that trades’ unionists never
have been very anxious as to the quality of their work till they
had piece-work to contend with, and I have never known workmen
produce such good work, as after a few experiences of having their
workmanship condemned for its bad quality, and the cost taken
out of their pockets. Under the old time wages no such effective
stimulus urged a man on to make his piece of work up to a proper
standard.”
What was true of the system as exemplified in Messrs Denny’s
experience previous to 1877, holds equally good for all the yards in
which piece-work is now the rule. Under it work is done quicker and
better than by the old system, and so popular is it amongst workmen
that a deep-rooted dislike for “time-work” prevails where piece-work
has once been instituted and efficiently managed.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account