Modern thinkers and present problems : $b an approach to modern philosophy through its historySinger, Edgar A. (Edgar Arthur)
Philosophy
Modern thinkers and present problems : $b an approach to modern philosophy through its history
Singer, Edgar A. (Edgar Arthur)
Philosophers; Philosophy -- History
But there is more than one sense in which this saying may be taken. We
have for example the Baconian thought, “knowledge is power.” That is,
given any end to be striven for, other things being equal the one who
brings science to bear is the more likely to conquer circumstances,
to triumph, to be free. This sense of the power of knowledge is not
lacking in Spinoza.
But the freedom that comes with knowledge may be of a higher kind than
the mere bettering of our chances of success. After all, human skill is
extremely limited; defeat is every man’s portion, and one of the most
important questions in life is how to bear failure.
If knowledge is our best arm to ward off defeat, so is it our best
solace when defeat, the inevitable, comes. For do we but understand
that the fate that has come upon us was not to be escaped but was
imposed by the eternal laws of nature, repining becomes impossible.
Pain is a fact, we cannot escape it altogether, we cannot deny it when
it has seized us. We _can_ though prevent the sourness and bitterness
that the ignorant fall prey to when they suffer. For pain is one thing,
hate another. Pain is not to be escaped; hate may be. And the way to
kill hate in our hearts is to connect the individual fact that is
painful with the whole order of nature which makes this as every other
fact necessary. Now the order of nature as we have seen flows from God
as the theorems of geometry flow from its axioms. To understand the
necessity of any fact is to recognize God as its cause. When we have
done this the bitterness of defeat is gone. No man, says Spinoza, can
hate God.
I have mentioned two senses in which knowledge meant freedom: (1) the
sense in which it reduces the chances of failure and pain to a minimum;
(2) the sense in which it frees us from the bondage of passion and
bitterness, when the unavoidable remainder of pain comes upon us. There
is still one deepest sense in which knowledge is freedom. So far, the
excellence of knowledge has been made to depend upon its fitness as a
means--either to the end of obtaining a maximum of success, or to the
end of bearing the still inevitable minimum of defeat. We have now to
consider knowledge as an end in itself.
Since, as we have seen, the pain of life is the sense of defeat, of
limitation; its pleasure the sense of triumph, of freedom, we should
expect to find Spinoza urging as the blessed way of life that one, if
any such there be, which could meet no defeat; that one whose success
did not hang upon circumstances in which a man’s life happened to be
cast; that life, in a word, that was at each moment absolute freedom.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account