Modern thinkers and present problems : $b an approach to modern philosophy through its historySinger, Edgar A. (Edgar Arthur)
Philosophy
Modern thinkers and present problems : $b an approach to modern philosophy through its history
Singer, Edgar A. (Edgar Arthur)
Philosophers; Philosophy -- History
Let us proceed to an immediate consequence of this last observation.
If no mechanical definition can be offered for a given term, it is
impossible that the things to which this term applies should be
governed by mechanical law. We may easily convince ourselves, however,
that although not subjected to mechanical law, they are frequently,
indeed generally, governed by another kind of law that is of the
greatest interest to us. Let me recur to our illustration of the
time-piece. There is a trite truth about time-pieces, which we may
say holds as a rule, to wit, that cheap time-pieces are poor ones.
Yet it would be meaningless to ask for a mechanical explanation of
this law, for the mechanical imperfection of the cheap sun dial bears
no resemblance whatever to the mechanical imperfection of the cheap
watch. The former may be a poor time-keeper because inexpensively
(and so grossly) graduated; the latter because the escapement is
inexpensively (and so crudely) constructed. So it is in the animal
world. Of its members we may lay down the rule, say, that each must eat
if it would live, but the physics and chemistry of nutrition in an oak
tree are so different from the physics and chemistry of nutrition in a
human being, that if anyone were to ask for a mechanical explanation of
this rule we could not offer it, or rather we should have to offer a
different one for each type of organism we considered. These examples
will be sufficient to illustrate the sense of the saying, “Beings whose
nature is not capable of mechanical definition cannot be subjected to
mechanical law.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account