Moral Principles and Medical Practice: The Basis of Medical JurisprudenceCoppens, Charles
Philosophy
Moral Principles and Medical Practice: The Basis of Medical Jurisprudence
Coppens, Charles
Medical ethics; Medical jurisprudence
"This low estimate of the importance of fœtal life is by no means
restricted to the ignorant or to the lower classes of society. Educated,
refined, and fashionable women, yea, in many instances, women whose
lives are in other respects without reproach--mothers who are devoted
with an ardent and self-denying affection to the children who already
constitute the family--are perfectly indifferent concerning the fœtus
_in utero_. They seem not to realize that the being within them is
indeed _animate_, that it is in verity a _human_ being, body and spirit;
that it is of importance; that its value is inestimable, having
reference to this world and the next. Hence they in every way neglect
its interests. They eat and drink, they walk and ride; they will
practise no self-restraint, but will indulge every caprice, every
passion, utterly regardless of the unseen, unloved embryo....
"These facts are horrible, but they are too frequent and too true;
often, very often, must all the eloquence and all the authority of the
practitioner be employed; often he must as it were grasp the conscience
of his weak and erring patient, and let her know, in language not to be
misunderstood, that she is responsible to her Creator for the life of
the being within her." (Wharton and Stillé's Med. Jur., Parturition,
p. 92.)
Dr. Walter Channing, of Massachusetts, refers to the difficulty of
obtaining a conviction for abortion, and adds: "I believe there has
never been one in this State, this moral State by eminence, and perhaps
in none is this crime more rife." ("Boston Med. and Surg. Journal,"
April, 1859, p. 135).
V. We have, then, proved, gentlemen, two important and pregnant
principles: 1. That we can never directly procure abortion, and 2, that
we can procure it indirectly in extreme cases; or rather that we can
take such extreme measures in pressing danger as may likely result in
abortion against our will.
While these principles are clear and undoubted, there are cases in which
the right application of them is beset with great difficulties. These
often occur in connection with what is called _ectopic_ or
_extra-uterine gestation_, namely, when the nascent human form lodges in
some recess not intended by nature for its abode. Of late years,
Dr. Velpeau, of Paris; Dr. Tait, of Birmingham, and many other eminent
physicians have shown that cases of ectopic gestation are more numerous
than had been supposed; one practitioner reports that he had attended
fifty cases, another eighty-five.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account