Music -- Physiological effect; Music, Influence of
Much has been written on the images or stories which musical
compositions evoke. Some musicians have tacitly implied that ability
to appreciate these stories results in greater pleasure, but
Gehring[34] wisely insists that “musical enjoyment does not depend on
interpretations, but it may also be reaped by those who abstain from
making them.” There are some people who can interpret any musical
selection, and others who find no story. Between these extremes is a
group who can get more pleasure from music if listening is preceded by
such preparation. As Damon[20] has pointed out, “A musical selection is
thought to be more beautiful and more colorful when the usual program
notes are supplied before hearing it.”
There are those who see specific color in sound. It was Isaac Newton
who first compared the diatonic scale with the seven colors of the
spectrum from red to violet beginning with C as red. Katz[71] reported
on strong color association of two case studies. For the first, C major
was jet black and for the other C major was brilliant white. But this
could be expected inasmuch as the scale of notes presents intervals
and proportions of the most definite kind whereas those of the color
spectrum are confluent and have no mathematic relation. Spectrum
analogy was discredited by de Marian in 1737[70]. “No two people
agree or hardly ever do, as to the color they associate with the same
sound”[30].
But color is only one element in a mental image; what about the others?
Is it possible for two people listening to a new, unnamed musical
selection for the first time to envisage the same story or picture?
T. Kawarski and H. Odbert[52] found no direct relationship between
color and music which held for more than a few individuals but certain
general relationships of photoism to special aspects of music were
found to recur constantly. Thus increase in brightness tends to
accompany rise in pitch or quickening of tempo. Whereas some one factor
like strong visual imagery or cultural influences or suggestions may be
dominant in some individuals and a totally different factor in another,
none of those factors operate in any pure and simple fashion.
Too often musical interpreters will see too much in a given selection.
Some will try to rhapsodize in words the theme as announced by the
title of the selection. Some enthusiasts will grasp at straws of
suggestion from the original source. Gurney cites an amusing instance
in connection with a sonata of Beethoven, of which the three movements
are entitled: _Les Adieux_, _L’Absence_, and _Le Retour_. These titles
were so inviting that some gushing comments were published about the
portrayal of passages from the life of two lovers. However, on the
manuscript, Beethoven wrote: “Farewell on the departure of His Imperial
Highness, the Archduke Rudolph, the 4th of May 1809.” and “Arrival of
his Imperial Highness, the Archduke Rudolph, the 30th of January 1810.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account