magnificent performance of the concluding "Dona nobis pacem."
[Sidenote: ="St. Matthew Passion."=
_January 25th, 1900._]
It is possible to regard the "St. Matthew Passion" of Sebastian Bach as
the greatest work of sacred musical art in existence, and thus as
greater than Handel's "Messiah"; while at the same time thoroughly
acquiescing in the greater popularity of the "Messiah." Handel was a
mighty artist and a most lordly person; but he was a man of the world
and a Court composer, and his religion, though perfectly genuine, was
external and official in character. Bach, too, was a mighty artist, but
he was not a man of the world. He was a devout and pious man and a man
of the people, and his religion was inward and personal. Again, Handel
was cosmopolitan, whereas Bach was thoroughly German. Not that Bach was
wanting in knowledge of Italian and other foreign music. He was a
perfectly comprehensive encyclopædia of the musical knowledge that
existed in his time. But the basis of his character was too homely,
simple and loyal to be modified by foreign influence. Thus while Handel
became musically an Italian, Bach remained thoroughly German. All these
circumstances suggest reasons for the much wider popularity of Handel's
music by comparison with Bach's. The general public like the clear and
definite outline, the structural simplicity, that they find in the
Italian and quasi-antique style of Handel, while they are bewildered by
the subtlety, the complexity, the varied imaginative play, and the
rejection of set forms that they find in Bach. It must be remembered
that the average man of the world to a great extent determines the tone
of the general public; one may be thankful that there exists any work
of sacred musical art so splendid as "Messiah," which is to a great
extent intelligible to the average man of the world, and one may rest
satisfied that, for the present at any rate, the "Messiah" should be
performed often, the Passion music seldom.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account