My Experiences in a Lunatic Asylum: By a Sane Patient — John Shaqi
My Experiences in a Lunatic Asylum: By a Sane PatientMerivale, Herman Charles
Science
My Experiences in a Lunatic Asylum: By a Sane Patient
Merivale, Herman Charles
Insanity (Law); Mentally ill -- Care
At last I reached the lowest rung of the medical ladder indeed; for what
the wine-trade is to the man who has failed generally, so I take it is the
lunacy trade (with marked and fine exceptions, of course) to the doctor
who is no good for any other 'specialty,' and knows he is not. His
province is the unknown; the law works for him; he is in charge of a
certain number of unfortunates, whom others--not he--have pronounced
'mad;' he argues, when he argues at all, backwards. He has not to say to
his patients, 'Your words and thoughts are inconsecutive, your eye is
wandering, &c.; therefore you are mad;' but, 'You are mad; therefore your
words and thoughts are inconsecutive, and your eye is wandering.' This
argument has been absolutely used in that shape with me; and I leave
honesty to judge what the effect was.
But I could not afford to be angry, for that would have been 'excitement'
and madder still. The position in which you put some of us--some of
you--with the light heart of M. Emile Ollivier--is a cruel and terrible
one, indeed, for the man conscious of sanity, but under the ban, ladies
and gentlemen. And believing, as I do, that I am one of the very few who
can ever have come through such an ordeal as this with all his wits
throughout about him, I cannot wonder for a moment that others have been
content to sit down quietly under this most intolerable wrong, and to hold
their tongues, lest 'excitement' should be again brought up against them.
But I will not, that is all. With all my heart I believe in the grand old
Sophoclean line, which used to console Mortimer Collins:
Οὐδεν ποθ' ἑρπει ψευδος εἰς γηρας χρονον.
For the benefit for those who have no Greek: 'No lie ever crawls to old
age.' And even in this coward world I believe truth is master when used as
the one fearless weapon, for attack or for defence.
But I have been growing 'excited,' good my readers, and I beg pardon. Some
of my friends are naturally afraid of any excitement on my part. It is not
easy to avoid sometimes. After this storm that has swept over my life,
there is a great strong current of righteous wrath that will run on deep
down beneath it to the end, but not more deep than I mean that it shall be
still. Out of the nettle danger I have plucked the rose of safety.
It was bitter winter when, as the beginning of the end, I was relegated to
the care of a good-natured young village medico, with about as much
knowledge of the buildings of the brain, I should think (and small blame
to him), as of Cambodian architecture. He was a kindly fellow, and did
all he could; but he dwelt in a tiny hamlet on the borders of one of the
dreariest tracts of our forest-country, and I reflect with sorrow to what
a stupendous extent I must have bored him. I am consoled by thinking that
I must have been of great value to him in his studies, as he was trying
his 'prentice hand in 'nervous' cases, to which he suspected himself of a
call, on me; and I wonder he failed to catch the malady.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account