My leper friends : $b An account of personal work among lepers, and of their daily life in IndiaHayes, Alice M.
History
My leper friends : $b An account of personal work among lepers, and of their daily life in India
Hayes, Alice M.
Leprosy -- Hospitals; Leprosy -- India
On May 15th reference was made in _Truth_ to a deplorable account
of the Leper Asylum, Calcutta, given by Mrs. Alice Hayes, in a
local paper called _Hayes’ Sporting News_. I have now received from
Mr. Justice Prinsep, president of the District Charitable Society,
which has the control of the Asylum in question, a letter in which
the writer states that the statements in _Hayes’ Sporting News_
“are absolutely without foundation, and are merely the careless and
inaccurate reports of a hysterical, irresponsible woman seeking for
notoriety.” Mr. Justice Prinsep does not deal with the whole of the
statements specifically, but he states (1) that in only one of the six
buildings “can it be pretended that there is any overcrowding at all;”
(2) “that the medical attendance is appropriate;” (3) “that a person
referred to by Mrs. Hayes as a native doctor is the ‘compounder;’” and
(4) that he could, if it were worth while, “similarly refute all Mrs.
Hayes’s statements.” He also sends me a copy of a letter addressed on
behalf of the management to the local press; but I find here quite
as much admission of the impeachment as denial. I find further that
in subsequent articles in _Hayes’ Sporting News_, Mrs. Hayes adheres
to her original statements, and points out that many of them are
unanswered or unanswerable. It is impossible for me at this distance
of time and space to go further into the matter, but the impression
left on my mind is that Mr. Justice Prinsep’s abusive language of
Mrs. Hayes is entirely unjustified, and that this Leper Asylum will
probably be all the better for the light that has been turned on it.
Mr. Prinsep, being a lawyer (he was Judge in the Calcutta High Court),
was well acquainted with the old legal maxim: “when you have got no
case, abuse the other side.” Consequently his strong language--however
unbecoming it was in a man of his high official position, and addressed
to a woman--was a convincing proof that the words I had written were
true. His assertion that I made a mistake in the designation of the
medical attendant, proves how sorely he was pressed to find something
to refute; for the fact of a “compounder” being lower in grade than a
“native doctor” made my case all the stronger.
I received not only a kindly pat on the back from Mr. Labouchere; but
a most sympathetic article under the heading, “A Lady’s Work Among the
Lepers,” appeared on the 22nd of the following November in _The Queen_,
as follows:--
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account