Narrative and Miscellaneous PapersDe Quincey, Thomas
General
Narrative and Miscellaneous Papers
De Quincey, Thomas
English essays; English fiction
Every way, you see, reader, there are difficulties. But two things
used to strike me, as unaccountably overlooked by Kant; who, to say the
truth, was profound--yet at no time very agile--in the character of his
understanding. First, what age now might we take our brother and
sister planets to be? For _that_ determination as to a point in _their_
constitution, will do something to illustrate our own. We are as good
as they, I hope, any day: perhaps in a growl, one might modestly
insinuate--_better_. It's not at all likely that there can be any
great disproportion of age amongst children of the same household: and
therefore, since Kant always countenanced the idea that Jupiter had
not quite finished the upholstery of his extensive premises, as a
comfortable residence for a man, Jupiter having, in fact, a fine family
of mammoths, but no family at all of 'humans,' (as brother Jonathan
calls them,) Kant was bound, _ex analogo_, to hold that any little
precedency in the trade of living, on the part of our own mother Earth,
could not count for much in the long run. At Newmarket, or Doncaster,
the start is seldom mathematically true: trifling advantages will
survive all human trials after abstract equity; and the logic of this
case argues, that any few thousands of years by which Tellus may have
got ahead of Jupiter, such as the having finished her Roman Empire,
finished her Crusades, and finished her French Revolution, virtually
amounts to little or nothing; indicates no higher proportion to the
total scale upon which she has to run, than the few tickings of a watch
by which one horse at the start for the Leger is in advance of another.
When checked in our chronology by each other, it transpires that, in
effect, we are but executing the nice manoeuvre of a start; and that the
small matter of six thousand years, by which we may have advanced
our own position beyond some of our planetary rivals, is but the
outstretched neck of an uneasy horse at Doncaster. This is _one_ of the
data overlooked by Kant; and the less excusably overlooked, because
it was his own peculiar doctrine,--that uncle Jupiter ought to be
considered a greenhorn. Jupiter may be a younger brother of our mamma;
but, if he is a brother at all, he cannot be so very wide of our own
chronology; and therefore the first _datum_ overlooked by Kant was--the
analogy of our whole planetary system. A second datum, as it always
occurred to myself, might reasonably enough be derived from the
intellectual vigor of us men. If our mother could, with any show of
reason, be considered an old decayed lady, snoring stentorously in
her arm-chair, there would naturally be some _aroma_ of phthisis, or
apoplexy, beginning to form about _us_, that are her children. But _is_
there? If ever Dr. Johnson said a true word, it was when he replied to
the Scottish judge Burnett, so well known to the world as Lord Monboddo.
The judge, a learned man, but obstinate as a mule in certain prejudices,
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account