Neurosyphilis : $b Modern systematic diagnosis and treatment presented in one hundred and thirty-seven case historiesSouthard, Elmer Ernest
Science
Neurosyphilis : $b Modern systematic diagnosis and treatment presented in one hundred and thirty-seven case histories
Southard, Elmer Ernest
Neurosyphilis
4. What is the classical differential diagnosis between paretic
neurosyphilis and neurasthenia? The testing of the blood by the W.
R. is unconditionally necessary. If the W. R. is negative, the
diagnosis of paretic neurosyphilis is extremely improbable. (It
must be borne in mind that a number of cases of paretic
neurosyphilis have been shown to have a negative W. R. in the
serum, and receive a proper diagnosis only after spinal fluid
examination.) Next to the serum W. R. stand the pupillary and
aphasic symptoms. In the presence of Argyll-Robertson pupil or
even a slight speech defect, the diagnosis of neurasthenia must
certainly be made with caution if at all. Kraepelin remarks: The
sudden occurrence of neurasthenic disorders in a male of middle
age without any evident cause therefor is always suspicious. Yet
it must be emphasized that a complaint of occasional dizziness,
slight speech defect, tremor of tongue, and a moderate increase of
tendon reflexes do not possess any marked diagnostic significance.
Clear insight and understanding of the nature of the disease
phenomena, a persistent search for recovery, reasonableness in
conversation, progressive improvement under appropriate treatment,
speak for neurasthenia.
Joffroy and Mignot differentiate what they call preparetic
neurasthenia from other neurasthenic states, not only on the basis
of its etiology but on the basis of its symptoms. They also call
attention to the fact that neurasthenia, being a pure neurosis,
develops either on a manifestly hereditary basis or upon some
physical injury, weakening disease, or moral shock. The pure
neurotic suffers a great deal more than the patient who is
destined to become a victim of paresis. The character change in
neurasthenia does not amount to that entire transformation of
personality (even to the performance of criminal acts) that we
find in paretic neurosyphilis; at the most, the neurasthenic shows
minor emotional disturbances and a certain pathological egoism.
The psychotherapeutic test also rather readily dissipates many of
the neurotic, hypochondriacal fears and feelings. Although both
pure neurasthenia and the paretic pseudoneurasthenia are
characterized by sexual weakness, the sexual anæsthesia of the
preparetic is practically always preceded by a stage of sexual
over-excitement. These finer clinical indications, however, fade
into insignificance beside the data that can and should be
obtained from laboratory tests.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account