Niebuhr's lectures on Roman history, Vol. 2 (of 3)Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
History
Niebuhr's lectures on Roman history, Vol. 2 (of 3)
Niebuhr, Barthold Georg
Rome -- History
The prospects of the Romans were very gloomy, the enemy being in Italy
with a superior force. And when they raised new legions, a great
disadvantage now shewed itself; for the veterans were lost, and the
Roman system of tactics was the very worst when the troops were not
well trained, (hence the defeat at Cannæ,) as, on the other hand, it
was the best with practised soldiers: they ought now to have formed in
phalanx only, so as to keep their ground by means of masses. Hannibal
had three roads before him, two of them through Tuscany, and one along
the Adriatic to Rimini; there lay the army of Sempronius, reinforced
by the fresh draughts which the new consul had brought with him. In
Tuscany, the Romans must have expected no attack whatever, nor does
any army seem to have been stationed there, unless perhaps an Etrurian
levy at most; for Hannibal met with no resistance at all when he had
resolved to go through the marshes. One of the roads was through the
Apennines, by Prato to Florence; the other, from Bologna by Pietramala
and Barberino, where the Apennines are broadest and wildest. The latter
of these must at that time have been impassable, having perhaps been
left to grow wild as a protection against the Gauls; it also passed too
close by the Apennines,[23] and Flaminius might have arrived before its
difficulties were overcome. He therefore chose the other road. With
regard to this, much dispute has unaccountably arisen, and even the
judicious and excellent Strabo is mistaken in thinking of the marshes
near Parma: in Tuscany, no one now has a doubt about it. The road in
question led by Lucca and Pisa. It is a very pleasant one now; but
formerly the outlet of the Arno was a shallow gulf running up into
the land as far as Sendi,[24] and this had been filled up from time
immemorial, and had become a marsh like the Pontine, only it was not
quite so unhealthy. Even now, on the northern side, one still sees a
succession of lakes, six German miles long; the marshes drained by
canals may everywhere be traced. This extends as far as Pisa, which
lies somewhat higher, and is connected with the fruitful country of
Lucca. Here, by Lucca where in spring all is a vast lake, we must
presume the march of Hannibal to have been. He had learned that it
was not a morass, but that it could be passed, although the whole way
was under water: the Romans, however, did not expect any inroad from
thence. Hannibal very likely went first to Modena, in order to deceive
the Romans, and then turned off to the right. The difficulties of the
march may have been somewhat exaggerated; but on the whole, there is
a correct notion at bottom. Hannibal lost very many men and horses,
and all his remaining elephants but one: he himself lost an eye. After
three days and a half, he got out near Fiesole, and marched behind
Florence into the upper valley of the Arno, which even as early as that
time was drained; and he allowed his soldiers, among whom there were
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account