Notes and Queries, Number 200, August 27, 1853: A Medium of Inter-communication for Literary Men, Artists, Antiquaries, Geneologists, etc.Various
History
Notes and Queries, Number 200, August 27, 1853: A Medium of Inter-communication for Literary Men, Artists, Antiquaries, Geneologists, etc.
Various
Questions and answers -- Periodicals
The word _building_ has always been a stumbling-block to editors. Johnson
first proposed to read _binding_, and his successors have adopted it, and
such is now the generally received reading. Mr. Collier's old corrector
is also in favour of the same change. I have always felt convinced,
however, that _building_ was the word which Shakspeare wrote. That
which answers to it in the A.-S. is _bytling_, _bytleing_, a building;
_bytlian_, to build; which are inflected from _byth_, _biotul_, a hammer
or mallet (whence our _beetle_); so that the strict meaning of the verb
is _firmare_, _confirmare_, to fasten, close, or bind together. This will
give much the same meaning to _building_ as that implied in the proposed
substitute _binding_.
Not having met with the word used in this peculiar sense by any old
writer, I could not venture to maintain the reading of the folio on
these grounds, which I have just mentioned, alone. At length, however, I
have been successful, and I am now able to quote a passage from a work
published very shortly before this play, entitled:
"The Jewel House of Art and Nature", &c., "faithfully and
familiarly set downe according to the Author's owne experience,
by Hugh Platte, of Lincoln's Inne, gentleman. London, 1594."
in which this word _building_ is used in precisely the same sense as that
which I defend. In "the Preface of the Author," the following passage
occurs:
"I made a condicionall promise of some farther discouerie in
arteficiall conceipts, then either my health {195} or leisure
would then permit: I am now resolued (notwithstanding the
vnkind acceptation of my first fruits, which then I feared and
hath since falne out, is a sufficient release in law of the
condition) to make the same in some sort absolute (though not
altogether according to the fulnesse of my first purpose), and
to become a _building_ word unto me."
I apprehend that this parallel instance is all that is wanting to
preserve, for the future, the reading of the first folio unimpaired.
The third passage on which I have a remark to offer, is that much
tormented one in Act III. Sc. 1., which stands in my first folio thus:
"_Cla._ The prenzie, Angelo?
_Isa._ Oh, 'tis the cunning liuerie of hell,
The damnest bodie to inuest, and couer
In prenzie gardes."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account