Notes and Queries, Number 238, May 20, 1854: A Medium of Inter-communication for Literary Men, Artists, Antiquaries, Genealogists, etc.Various
History
Notes and Queries, Number 238, May 20, 1854: A Medium of Inter-communication for Literary Men, Artists, Antiquaries, Genealogists, etc.
Various
Questions and answers -- Periodicals
2. The metrical version of Tate and Brady, and that of Archdeacon Prys.
3. Dr. Watts's metrical version and a Welsh imitation of it.
_Letters in three Welsh Versions._
_Bible._ _Prys._ _Watts._
Consonants 185 205 241
Vowels 148 165 159
--- --- ---
Apparent excess of }
consonants in Welsh } 37 40 82
_Letters in three English Versions._
_Bible._ _Tate & Brady._ _Watts._
Consonants 220 271 275
Vowels 134 163 170
--- --- ---
Apparent excess of }
consonants in English } 86 108 105
_Sounds in three Welsh Versions._
_Bible._ _Prys._ _Watts._
Consonants 150 173 200
Vowels 148 165 159
--- --- ---
Real excess of consonants}
in Welsh } 2 8 41
_Sounds in three English Versions._
_Bible._ _Tate & Brady._ _Watts._
Consonants 195 241 240
Vowels 122 149 159
--- --- ---
Real excess of consonants}
in English } 73 92 81
From this analysis it appears that the excess of consonant _letters_ over
vowels is, in English, 299; and in Welsh, 159, a little more than one-half.
The excess of consonant _sounds_ is, in English, 246; in Welsh, 51,
considerably less than one-fourth.
This result might readily have been anticipated by anybody familiar with
the following facts:
1. On examining lists of the elementary sounds of both languages, it will
be found that the Welsh has a greater number of vowels than the English,
and the English a greater number of consonants than the Welsh.
2. Welsh diphthongs are much more numerous than English.
3. In English, _three_ vowels only constitute words in themselves (_a_,
article; _I_, pronoun; _O_, interjection), and each is used only in one
sense. In Welsh, _five_ of the vowels (_a_, _e_, _i_, _o_, _y_) are words;
and they are used in at least a dozen different significations. _A_,
besides being an affirmative and interrogative adverb, answers to the
English _and_, _as_, _with_, _will go_.
4. Diphthongs forming distinct words are much more numerous in Welsh than
in English. The following occur: _ai_, _a'i_ (=_a ei_), _a'u_, _ei_, _eu_,
_ia_, _ïe_, _i'w_, _o'i_, _o'u_, _ow_, _[^w]y_, _yw_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account