(1) _What_ is Nature? = What are the facts
which constitute Nature. (Knowledge
of Nature).
(2) _How_ has Nature come to be what she is?
= How is it that facts constituting
Nature have become as we perceive
them? (Explanation of Nature).
(3) _Why_ is Nature as she is and not otherwise?
= Why is it that facts constituting
Nature have a certain uniformity
(order) continuity and unity in spite of
changes that take place continuously?
(Reason of Nature).
Broadly speaking, I may say that Science (with its various departments
called "Sciences") tries to answer the first question _what_, the
question as to _facts_ of Nature. Philosophy tries to answer the second
question _how_, the question as to the _explanation_ of Nature. Religion
or Theology (which includes highest Poetry) tries to answer the third
and last question _why_, the question as to the _reason_ of Nature. You
may thus clearly remember the respective provinces of Science,
Philosophy and Religion by remembering three words What, How and Why.
When you read a book which treats of facts or the _what_ of Nature; or
of the explanation or the _how_ of her; or of the reason or the _why_ of
her; you may be sure it is Science, Philosophy or Religion respectively
that you are reading, whatever be the name of the book itself.
I have said that Science, Philosophy or Religion "_tries_ to answer" and
not "answers", because the answer of any of them can never be final or
immutable. None of them can ever reach finality. As the experience of
mankind grows continuously, new facts or new phases of old facts are
discovered in the course of time. Just as men have to adapt or adjust
themselves to new facts (or to changes in old facts) or else die; so
men's Science, Philosophy and Theology have to adjust themselves to new
facts or else become empty nothings.[85]
II.
I have often said that I believe Islam to be the best religion because
(so far as I know) it accords best with the current ideas of Science. If
you accept my view of the respective provinces of Science, Philosophy,
and Religion, you can easily comprehend that a Religion like Islam
which purports to expound the reason _why_ of Nature must needs
correspond with the _what_ (Science) as well as with the _how_
(Philosophy) of Nature. The three great divisions of Human Thought--I
mean, Science, Philosophy and Religion--are necessarily connected with
one another, as otherwise they cannot make up _the whole Universe of
Human Thought_ and cannot satisfy men's craving for complete and
consistent knowledge.
III.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account