The same, I fear, might now be said of Muhammadanism. But to my mind
there is no fixity, no absolute truth in any form of religious dogma.
Religion is a thing that must grow with man's intelligence; it is not a
box of spiritual truths packed once and for ever, and unpacked for the
gaze of successive generations. It is not enough to believe in certain
facts that happened long ago, or to obey certain injunctions given long
ago in a particular country; we must apply the spirit of a religion to
the circumstances in which we live. We shall never attain to final
absolute truth, "the end is not yet, and the purposes of God to man are
but half revealed" (Jowett).
Unfortunately when any religion has taken itself as final it has
developed a priesthood, and that priesthood has been apt to lay down a
code of fixed rules wherewith alone compliance is required. It is a
fatally easy thing to live in conformity with any definite code of
rules. Muhammad himself, I imagine, was a singularly liberal
theologian. He laid down certain regulations for the conduct of life,
excellent considering his place and time; the modern Muhammadan has
accepted these as a maximum spiritual demand, ignoring the fact that
they probably represented the minimum demands of common sense in
Muhammad's time and country.
Muhammad directed that a Muhammadan should not drink alcohol. This is a
maxim of excellent sense in Arabia; Haji Burton, who much appreciated
good wine, has told us that in the Arabian deserts wine is positively
distasteful as well as unwholesome. I have not the least desire that
Muhammadans should drink wine. I merely say that there is no _merit_,
other than that of common sense, in obeying this excellent instruction
in countries wherein circumstances render it excellent. I do not believe
that Muhammad would find the least fault with disregard of his maxim in
countries where the climate makes the _moderate_ drinking of wine both
pleasant and beneficial.
Muhammad instituted the Ramzan fast, mainly, I am told, to harden his
soldiers. But the Muhammadan of to-day finds a positive merit in
fasting. There is none; else the jockey's profession comprises the most
virtuous men in the world.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account