Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
15. These lessons are of the highest value with regard to all
employments of the human mind; for the mode in which words in common
use acquire their meaning, approaches far more nearly to the _Method
of_ {177} _Type_ than to the method of definition. The terms which
belong to our practical concerns, or to our spontaneous and
unscientific speculations, are rarely capable of exact definition.
They have been devised in order to express assertions, often very
important, yet very vaguely conceived: and the signification of the
word is extended, as far as the assertion conveyed by it can be
extended, by apparent connexion or by analogy. And thus, in all the
attempts of man to grasp at knowledge, we have an exemplification of
that which we have stated as the rule of induction, that Definition
and Proposition are mutually dependent, each adjusted so as to give
value and meaning to the other: and this is so, even when both the
elements of truth are defective in precision: the Definition being
replaced by an incomplete description or a loose reference to a
Type; and the Proposition being in a corresponding degree insecure.
16. Thus the study of Natural History, as a corrective of the belief
that definitions are essential to substantial truth, might be of
great use; and the advantage which might thus be obtained is such as
well entitles this study to a place in a liberal education. We may
further observe, that in order that Natural History may produce such
an effect, it must be studied by inspection of the _objects_
themselves, and not by the reading of books only. Its lesson is,
that we must in all cases of doubt or obscurity refer, not to words
or definitions, but to things. The Book of Nature is its dictionary:
it is there that the natural historian looks, to find the meaning of
the words which he uses[20\3]. So {178} long as a plant, in its most
essential parts, is more _like_ a rose than any thing else, it _is_
a rose. He knows no other definition.
[Note 20\3: It is a curious example of the influence of the belief
in definitions, that elementary books have been written in which
Natural History is taught in the way of question and answer, and
consequently by means of words alone. In such a scheme, of course
all objects are _defined_: and we may easily anticipate the value of
the knowledge thus conveyed. Thus, 'Iron is a well-known hard metal,
of a darkish gray colour, and very elastic:' 'Copper is an
orange-coloured metal, more sonorous than any other, and the most
elastic of any except iron.' This is to pervert the meaning of
education, and to make it a business of mere words.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account