Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
13. The mode in which, in this and in other cases, the Method of
Natural Classification directs the researches of the philosopher, is
this:--his arrangement being adopted, at least as an instrument of
inquiry and trial, he follows the course of the different members of
the classification, according to the guidance which Nature herself
offers; not prescribing beforehand the marks of each part, but
distributing the facts according to the total resemblances, or
according to those resemblances which he finds to be most important.
Thus, in tracing the course of a series of strata from place to
place, we identify each stratum, not by any single character, but by
all taken together;--texture, colour, fossils, position, and any
other circumstances which offer themselves. And if, by this means,
we come to ambiguous cases, where different indications appear to
point different ways, we decide so as best to preserve undamaged
those general relations and truths which constitute the value of our
system. Thus although we consider the organic fossils in each
stratum as its most important characteristic, we are not prevented,
by the disappearance of some fossils, or the addition of others, or
by the total absence of fossils, {230} from identifying strata in
distant countries, if the position and other circumstances authorize
us to do so. And by this Method of Classification, the doctrine of
_Geological Equivalents_[48\3] has been applied to a great part of
Europe.
[Note 48\3: _Hist. Ind. Sc._ b. xviii. c. iii. sect. 4.]
14. We may further observe, that the same method of natural
classification which thus enables us to identify strata in remote
situations, notwithstanding that there may be great differences in
their material and contents, also forbids us to assume the identity
of the series of rocks which occur in different countries, when this
identity has not been verified by such a continuous exploration of
the component members of the series. It would be in the highest
degree unphilosophical to apply the special names of the English or
German strata to the rocks of India, or America, or even of southern
Europe, till it has appeared that in those countries the geological
series of northern Europe really exists. In each separate country,
the divisions of the formations which compose the crust of the earth
must be made out, by applying the Method of Natural Arrangement _to
that particular case_, and not by arbitrarily extending to it the
nomenclature belonging to another case. It is only by such
precautions, that we can ever succeed in obtaining geological
propositions, at the same time true and comprehensive; or can obtain
any sound general views respecting the physical history of the
earth.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account