Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
15. The Method of Natural Classification, which we thus recommend,
falls in with those mental habits which we formerly described as
resulting from the study of Natural History. The method was then
termed the _Method of Type_, and was put in opposition to the
_Method of Definition_.
The Method of Natural Classification is directly opposed to the
process in which we assume and apply _arbitrary_ definitions; for in
the former Method, we find our classes in nature, and do not make
them by marks of our own imposition. Nor can any advantage {231} to
the progress of knowledge be procured, by laying down our characters
when our arrangements are as yet quite loose and unformed. Nothing
was gained by the attempts to _define_ Metals by their weight, their
hardness, their ductility, their colour; for to all these marks, as
fast as they were proposed, exceptions were found, among bodies
which still could not be excluded from the list of Metals. It was
only when elementary substances were divided into _Natural Classes_,
of which classes Metals were one, that a true view of their
distinctive characters was obtained. Definitions in the outset of
our examination of nature are almost always, not only useless, but
prejudicial.
16. When we obtain a Law of Nature by induction from phenomena, it
commonly happens, as we have already seen, that we introduce, at the
same time, a Proposition and a Definition. In this case, the two are
correlative, each giving a real value to the other. In such cases,
also, the Definition, as well as the Proposition, may become the
basis of rigorous reasoning, and may lead to a series of deductive
truths. We have examples of such Definitions and Propositions in the
Laws of Motion, and in many other cases.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account