Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
The introduction of this chemical language can never cease to be
considered one of the most important steps ever made in the
improvement of technical terms; and as a signal instance of the
advantages which may result from artifices apparently trivial, if
employed in a manner conformable to the laws of phenomena, and
systematically pursued. It was, however, proved that {276} this
language, with all its merits, had some defects. The relations of
elements in composition were discovered to be more numerous than the
modes of expression which the terminations supplied. Besides the
sulphurous and sulphuric acids, it appeared there were others; these
were called the _hyposulphurous_ and _hyposulphuric_: but these
names, though convenient, no longer implied, by their form, any
definite relation. The compounds of Nitrogen and Oxygen are, in
order, the _Protoxide_, the _Deutoxide_ or _Binoxide_; _Hyponitrous_
Acid, _Nitrous_ Acid, and _Nitric_ Acid. The nomenclature here
ceases to be systematic. We have three oxides of Iron, of which we
may call the first the _Protoxide_, but we cannot call the others
the _Deutoxide_ and _Trioxide_, for by doing so we should convey a
perfectly erroneous notion of the proportions of the elements. They
are called the _Protoxide_, the _Black_ Oxide, and the _Peroxide_.
We are here thrown back upon terms quite unconnected with the
system.
Other defects in the nomenclature arose from errours in the theory;
as for example the names of the muriatic, oxymuriatic, and
hyperoxymuriatic acids; which, after the establishment of the new
theory of chlorine, were changed to _hydrochloric_ acid, _chlorine_,
and _chloric_ acid.
Thus the chemical system of nomenclature, founded upon the oxygen
theory, while it shows how much may be effected by a good and
consistent scheme of terms, framed according to the real relations
of objects, proves also that such a scheme can hardly be permanent
in its original form, but will almost inevitably become imperfect
and anomalous, in consequence of the accumulation of new facts, and
the introduction of new generalizations. Still, we may venture to
say that such a scheme does not, on this account, become worthless;
for it not only answers its purpose in the stage of scientific
progress to which it belongs:--so far as it is not erroneous, or
merely conventional, but really systematic and significant of truth,
its terms can be translated at once into the language of any higher
generalization which is afterwards arrived at. If terms express
{277} relations really ascertained to be true, they can never lose
their value by any change of the received theory. They are like
coins of pure metal, which, even when carried into a country which
does not recognize the sovereign whose impress they bear, are still
gladly received, and may, by the addition of an explanatory mark,
continue part of the common currency of the country.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account