Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
We may add that, in consequence of these different practices in the
two languages, it is a common habit of the German reader to impose a
scientific definiteness upon a common word, such as our Fifth
Aphorism requires; whereas the English reader expects rather that a
word which is to have a technical sense shall be derived from the
learned languages. _Die Kelch_ and _die Blume_ (the cup and the
flower) easily assume the technical meaning of _calyx_ and
_corolla_; _die Griffel_ (the pencil) becomes _the pistil_; and a
name is easily found for the _pollen_, the _anthers_, and the
_stamens_, by calling them the dust, the dust-cases, and the
dust-threads (_der Staub_, _die Staub-beutel_, or _Staub-fächer_,
and _die Staub-fäden_), This was formerly done in English to a
greater extent than is now possible without confusion and pedantry.
Thus, in Grew's book on the _Anatomy of Plants_, the calyx is called
the _impalement_, and the sepals the _impalers_; the petals are
called the _leaves of the flower_; the stamens with their anthers
are the _seminiform attire_. But the English language, as to such
matters, is now less flexible than it was; partly in consequence of
its having adopted the Linnæan terminology almost entire, without
any endeavour to naturalize it. Any attempt at idiomatic description
would interfere with the scientific language now generally received
in this country. In Germany, on the other hand, those who first
wrote upon science in their own language imitated the Latin words
which they found in foreign writers, instead of transferring new
roots into their own language. Thus the _Numerator_ and
_Denominator_ of a fraction they call the _Namer_ and the _Counter_
(_Nenner_ and _Zähler_). This course they pursued even where the
expression was erroneous. Thus that portion of the intestines which
ancient anatomists called _Duodenum_, because they falsely estimated
its length at twelve inches, the {322} Germans also term
_Zwölffingerdarm_ (twelve-inch-gut), though this intestine in a
whale is twenty feet long, and in a frog not above twenty lines. As
another example of this process in German, we may take the word
_Muttersackbauchblatte_, the _uterine peritonæum_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account