Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciencesWhewell, William
Philosophy
Novum organon renovatum: Being the second part of the philosophy of the inductive sciences
Whewell, William
Science -- Philosophy
In order to do this, we must reconsider, in a more definite and
precise shape, the doctrine which has already been laid down;--that
our Knowledge consists {29} in applying Ideas to Facts; and that the
conditions of real knowledge are that the ideas be distinct and
appropriate, and exactly applied to clear and certain facts. The
steps by which our knowledge is advanced are those by which one or
the other of these two processes is rendered more complete;--by
which _Conceptions_ are _made more clear_ in themselves, or by which
the Conceptions more strictly _bind together the Facts_. These two
processes may be considered as together constituting the whole
formation of our knowledge; and the principles which have been
established in the History of Scientific Ideas bear principally upon
the former of these two operations;--upon the business of elevating
our conceptions to the highest possible point of precision and
generality. But these two portions of the progress of knowledge are
so clearly connected with each other, that we shall deal with them
in immediate succession. And having now to consider these operations
in a more exact and formal manner than it was before possible to do,
we shall designate them by certain constant and technical phrases.
We shall speak of the two processes by which we arrive at science,
as _the Explication of Conceptions_ and _the Colligation of Facts_:
we shall show how the discussions in which we have been engaged have
been necessary in order to promote the former of these offices; and
we shall endeavour to point out modes, maxims, and principles by
which the second of the two tasks may also be furthered.
{{30}}
CHAPTER II.
OF THE EXPLICATION OF CONCEPTIONS.
APHORISM II.
_The Explication of Conceptions, as requisite for the progress of
science, has been effected by means of discussions and controversies
among scientists; often by debates concerning definitions; these
controversies have frequently led to the establishment of a
Definition; but along with the Definition, a corresponding
Proposition has always been expressed or implied. The essential
requisite for the advance of science is the clearness of the
Conception, not the establishment of a Definition. The construction
of an exact Definition is often very difficult. The requisite
conditions of clear Conceptions may often be expressed by Axioms as
well as by Definitions._
APHORISM III.
_Conceptions, for purposes of science, must be_ appropriate _as well
as clear: that is, they must be modifications of_ that _Fundamental
Idea, by which the phenomena can really be interpreted. This maxim
may warn us from errour, though it may not lead to discovery.
Discovery depends upon the previous cultivation or natural clearness
of the appropriate Idea, and therefore_ no discovery is the work of
accident.
SECT. I.--_Historical Progress of the Explication of Conceptions._
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account