My present business is with the Yankee declaration, that English
authors to be readable in America must be passed through the ordeal
of re-writing. I scarcely think that the annals of impertinence and
ignorance could equal this. What! is it seriously meant that Scott and
Byron, Wordsworth, Southey, Rogers, Bulwer, James, Dickens, and a host
of others, must be converted into the garbage of St. Giles, or the
foetid slang of Wapping, before they can pass muster before an American
public? Must the book reek of “gin twist,” “cock tail,” and fifty
other abominations, ere it reach an American drawing-room? Must the
“bowie-knife and the whittling-stick” mark its pages; and the coarse
jest of some tobacco-chewing, wildcat-whipping penny-a-liner disfigure
and sully the passages impressed with the glowing brilliancy of Scott,
or the impetuous torrent of Byron's genius? Is this a true picture of
America? Is her reading public indeed degraded to this pass? I certainly
have few sympathies with brother Jonathan. I like not his spirit of
boastful insolence, his rude speech, or his uncultivated habits; but I
confess I am unwilling to credit this. I hesitate to believe in such
an amount of intellectual depravity as can turn from the cultivated
writings of Scott and Bulwer to revel in the coarseness and vulgarity
of a Yankee editor, vamping up his stolen wares with oaths from the far
west, or vapid jests from life in the Prairies. Again, what shall I say
of those who follow this traffic? Is it not enough to steal that which
is not theirs, to possess themselves of what they have no right or claim
to? Must they mangle the corpse when they have extinguished life? Must
they, while they cheat the author of his gain, rob him also of his
fair fame? “He who steals my purse steals trash,” but how shall I
characterise that extent of baseness that dares to step in between an
author and his reputation--inserting between him and posterity their own
illiterate degeneracy and insufferable stupidity?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account