To my mind—even apart from the sufficiently appalling factor of being
systematically trained for wholesale killing and subjected to the risk of
being killed in brutal war—there are few if any more evil and perilous
situations to put young men into than the armed forces. I should feel
much deeper grief over having possibly had some part in getting some
youth to go into the armed forces than over having some responsibility
for bringing a young man to go to prison for conscience’s sake. Are
the qualms people feel about youthful COs going to prison in certain
instances perhaps due to the fact that taking the non-registrant position
is something very unusual and regarded with social disapproval, whereas
becoming a soldier is extremely common and meets with the highest social
approval? It may be, therefore, that there are some ministers and other
older people who should examine themselves as to whether their feelings
in the matter under discussion are due to the fact that they themselves
might find life in the community or in the church very uncomfortable
if they were suspected of having influenced a youth to take a radical
anti-draft stand, whereas all men will speak well of them—or at least not
too ill—if they have helped, or at least not hindered, young Christians
in adjusting themselves to the idea of going into the army. Is it just
possible that we older people are sometimes concerned with sparing
ourselves when we think we are solely concerned about sparing teen-agers?
To return to the 18-year-old. There are young men who on physical and
psychological grounds are exempted from army service. There may well be
COs who should on similar grounds be exempted from any kind of service.
If such a physically or mentally ill CO is refused exemption, he should
perhaps be discouraged from undergoing the risks of prison experience if
there is an alternative for him. This still leaves us with the problem of
the majority of pacifist and non-pacifist youth who are not ill.
When we find ourselves concerned about what the teen-age religious CO who
goes to prison must undergo and inclined to think that there is here an
absolutely conclusive case for providing alternative service and urging
most such COs to avail themselves of it, we might first take a look at
two other categories of youth who are subject to the draft. One of them
consists of those actually drafted into the armed services; the other of
the so-called non-religious COs.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account