As pacifists we are opposed to all war. Even if recruitment were entirely
on a voluntary basis, we would be opposed. It seems to me we might
infer from this that we should be _a fortiori_ opposed to military
conscription, for here in addition to the factor of war itself, the
element of coercion by government enters in, coercion which places young
boys in a military regime where they are deprived of freedom of choice
in virtually all essential matters. They may not have the slightest
interest in the war, yet they are made to kill by order. This is surely a
fundamental violation of the human spirit which must cause the pacifist
to shudder.
The reply is sometimes made that pacifists are _not_ being conscripted
for military purposes and therefore—presumably—_they_ are not faced
with the issue of the nature of military conscription. I shall later
contend that it is not really possible to separate conscription and war,
as I think this argument does. Here I wish to suggest that even if the
question is the conscription of non-pacifist youth, it is a fundamental
mistake for pacifists ever to relent in their opposition to this evil,
ever to devote their energies primarily to securing provisions for COs
in a draft law or to lapse into a feeling that conscription has somehow
become more palatable if such provisions are made by the State. It is
not our own children if we are pacifist parents, our fellow-pacifist
Christians if we are churchmen, about whom we should be most deeply
concerned. In the first place, that is a narrow and perhaps self-centered
attitude. In the second place, pacifist youths have some inner resources
for meeting the issue under discussion. The terrible thing which we
should never lose sight of, to which we should never reconcile our
spirits, is that the great mass of 18-year-olds are drafted for war. They
are given no choice. Few are at the stage of development where they are
capable of making fully rational and responsible choice. Thus the fathers
immolate the sons, the older generation immolates the younger, on the
altar of Moloch. What God centuries ago forbade Abraham to do even to his
own son—“Lay not thy hand upon the lad, neither do thou anything unto
him”—this we do by decree to the entire youth of a nation.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account