Olympic Victor Monuments and Greek Athletic ArtHyde, Walter Woodburn
History
Olympic Victor Monuments and Greek Athletic Art
Hyde, Walter Woodburn
Olympics; Sculpture, Greek; Sports -- Greece
In the foregoing comparison, we have tacitly assumed that this marble
head is from an athlete statue, and, moreover, that it, as the _Agias_,
represents a victor in the pankration, though many have seen in it
the representation not of a victor, but of a youthful Herakles.[2075]
The swollen ears and the band in the hair might pass equally well for
either, just as the fact that it was unearthed near the ruins of the
Great Gymnasion (if it were necessary to assume that the statue once
stood there) might be adduced as evidence for either interpretation;
for statues of athletes as well as those of Herakles and Hermes (as
we have shown in Ch. II)[2076] adorned palæstræ and gymnasia. That
the head is of marble and slightly under life-size seems to lend
some support also to the belief that it is a fragment of a statue of
Herakles, on the assumption that statues of victors in the Altis were
uniformly of bronze, an assumption, however, not supported by the
facts, as will be shown in Chapter VII. So some have seen the heroic
features of the youthful hero in the γοργόν of the eyes, the energetic
forehead, closely cropped hair, muscular neck, and almost challenging
inclination of the head seemingly corresponding with an energetic
raising of the left shoulder.[2077] In Chapter III we saw that swollen
ears were of little use in determining whether a given head belongs
to the statue of a victor or to one of Herakles, since they formed no
personal characteristic, but only a professional one common to athletes
and to gods, if these latter were concerned with athletics.[2078] Where
personal attributes are absent, it is often difficult, therefore, to
determine whether an ideal athlete or Herakles is intended, for it may
be the hero in the guise of the athlete, or an athlete in the guise of
the hero. The head under discussion, then, may furnish merely another
illustration of the process of assimilation of type which we have
already discussed. Thus it is not surprising that some have regarded
this head as that of a youthful Herakles. Yet such a view is wrong;
for, apart from all considerations which we shall adduce to identify it
with the Akarnanian pancratiast, and in the absence of distinguishing
attributes, if we compare it with another Lysippan head from a statue
generally recognized as that of a Herakles—the famous Pentelic marble
one in Lansdowne House, London (Pl. 30 and Fig. 71),[2079] which
Michaelis long ago characterized as “unmistakably in the spirit of
Lysippos”—we can see how fundamentally different is the whole spiritual
conception of the two, and how differently an athlete (even if highly
idealized) and a hero are treated by the same sculptor. If we once
recognize a victor in the head from Olympia, then the swollen ears, the
fierce, barbarous look of the eyes, and the half-painful expression of
the mouth, all concur in convincing us that we here have to do with a
victor in boxing or the pankration, the two most brutal and dangerous
contests.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account