On criminal abortion in AmericaStorer, Horatio Robinson
Philosophy
On criminal abortion in America
Storer, Horatio Robinson
Abortion -- United States
It was Orfila’s opinion that criminal abortion was most frequent in the
two first months of pregnancy. This would naturally have been supposed
the case, as then some doubt might always obtain regarding its existence,
and the excuse that the measures resorted to were for the purpose of
preventing ill effect from an abnormal menstrual suppression would be
more available. Devergie, on the other hand, was inclined to put the
limits of greatest frequency at from three months to four and a half;
while Briand and Chaudé thought the crime more common in the third month
than the fifth, and in this last month much more frequent than even in
the first or second. Tardieu also came to a similar conclusion.[95] He
ascertained, that of 34 cases investigated by himself, 25 were in from
the third to the sixth month, most in the third; 5 in the first two
months; 4 in the seventh and eighth; or that the cases in the third
month, or shortly after, were five times as numerous as at either an
earlier or a later period, and nearly three times as numerous as in both
combined.
Upon examining the Register of the Morgue, we find its statistics
strikingly corroborative of these deductions. We have already seen that
from 1837-54 there had been deposited at the Morgue 692 fœtuses of less
than nine months. Of these,
23 were from the first to the second month;
79 ” ” second to the third;
108 ” ” third to the fourth;
158 ” ” fourth to the fifth;
150 ” ” fifth to the sixth;
97 ” ” sixth to the seventh;
48 ” ” seventh to the eighth;
29 ” ” eighth to the ninth.
It has been stated that 519, or five-sixths of them all, were not over
six months, and it now appears that on a scale twenty times larger
than that given by Tardieu from his own experience, nearly two-thirds
of the fœtal deaths induced by abortion were in from the third to the
sixth month of pregnancy; the three periods included giving a much
larger proportion than any others, and the two last of them being almost
identical. The extreme paucity shown by the above table in the first
and ninth months, and the decrease in the seventh and eighth from those
preceding, are worthy of remark. It is probable that the sudden increase
may be attributed to mental reaction after the first shock occasioned
by the absolute certainty of pregnancy is past; and the subsequent
decrease to the fact that in many attempted criminal abortions during the
later months children are born alive, the mother’s courage then proving
insufficient for infanticide and its greater and more probable punishment.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account