And for an analogous reason, wise men know that in the ’Varsity
boat-race it is judicious and prudent to bet on the heavier crew.
Leaving aside the question of the supply of energy, and keeping to
that of the mechanical efficiency of the machine, we may find endless
biological illustrations of the principle of similitude.
In the case of the flying bird (apart from the initial difficulty of
raising itself into the air, which involves another problem) it may be
shewn that the bigger it gets (all its proportions remaining the same)
the more difficult it is for it to maintain itself aloft in flight. The
argument is as follows:
In order to keep aloft, the bird must communicate to the air a downward
momentum equivalent to its own weight, and therefore proportional
to _the cube of its own linear dimensions_. But the momentum so
communicated is proportional to the mass of air driven downwards, and
to the rate at which it is driven: the mass being proportional to the
bird’s wing-area, and also (with any given slope of wing) to the speed
of the bird, and the rate being again proportional to the bird’s speed;
accordingly the whole momentum varies as the wing-area, i.e. as _the
square of the linear dimensions, and also as the square of the speed_.
Therefore, in order that the bird may maintain level flight, its speed
must be proportional to _the square root of its linear dimensions_.
Now the rate at which the bird, in steady flight, has to work in order
to drive itself forward, is the rate at which it communicates energy to
the air; and this is proportional to _m_ _V_^2, i.e. to the mass and
to the square of the velocity of the air displaced. But the mass of
air displaced per second is proportional to the wing-area and to the
speed of the bird’s motion, and therefore to the power 2½ of the linear
dimensions; and the speed at which it is displaced is proportional
to the bird’s speed, and therefore to the square root of the linear
dimensions. Therefore the energy communicated per second (being
proportional to the mass and to the square of the speed) is jointly
proportional to the power 2½ of the linear dimensions, as above, and
to the first power thereof: {25} that is to say, it increases in
proportion _to the power_ 3½ _of the linear dimensions_, and therefore
faster than the weight of the bird increases.
Put in mathematical form, the equations are as follows:
(_m_ = the mass of air thrust downwards; _V_ its velocity, proportional
to that of the bird; _M_ its momentum; _l_ a linear dimension of the
bird; _w_ its weight; _W_ the work done in moving itself forward.)
_M_ = _w_ = _l_^3.
But _M_ = _m_ _V_, and _m_ = _l_^2 _V_.
Therefore _M_ = _l_^2 _V_^2,
and _l_^2 _V_^2 = _l_^3,
or _V_ = √_l_.
But, again, _W_ = _m_ _V_^2 = _l_^2 _V_ × _V_^2
= _l_^2 × √_l_ × _l_
= _l_^{3½}.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account