Statistics do not favour the immediate operation, for although some
surgeons have obtained good results, the mortality with others has been
considerable. Thus König,[68] on the one hand, records seventy cases
operated on in the first month with but one death; whilst Hermann[69]
gives 52·4 per cent. as the mortality of the operation during the first
three months of life, and Gotthelf[70] 50 per cent. for a similar
period. The latter cannot but be considered as an extraordinarily high
death-rate, and possibly antiseptic precautions were not carefully
observed. Trendelenburg[71] reports 44 cases treated in the course of
three years with seven deaths; the infants were between three and six
months old. Fifteen were simple cases, with one death; twenty-one were
complicated, with two deaths; and eight most complex forms, with four
deaths. Only one died within a fortnight of the operation; the remainder
from intercurrent maladies. Still, however, he reckons the death-rate
during the first year of life of children operated on as 41·6 per cent.,
explaining it by malnutrition and the want of intelligent artificial
feeding. Fritzsche reckons the mortality during the first two weeks after
operation as about 5 per cent., but even this is higher than I should
consider consistent with the results of British surgery.
My own personal experience has been much more satisfactory, and the above
figures are much too high to represent my results. Out of between 300 and
400 cases treated between the fourth and eighth weeks, _i. e._ by the
early operation, I have had no death as an immediate result, but several
have died subsequently from intercurrent maladies or defective nutrition.
I attribute this success largely to the fact that I never operate upon
out-patients, but always take the precaution of carefully preparing and
watching them for a few days prior to operating. In the practice of
the late Sir W. Fergusson the one or two fatal cases which I recollect
occurred in children who were taken home immediately after the operation.
It has been claimed for the deferred operation that convulsions are
liable to ensue when an infant under six months is operated on, and also
that the interdiction of nursing impairs nutrition; but this has not been
my experience.
From a consideration of the foregoing facts, it would appear that from
the fourth week to the third month is the most favorable period for
interference, and that at which the greatest proportion of success has
been obtained.
In conclusion, whilst fully admitting that it is impossible to lay down
rules which will meet every case, and that each must be dealt with on its
own merits, I would venture to suggest the following propositions which
may be helpful as a guide to practice:
1. That, _cæteris paribus_, it is important to close the cleft in the lip
as early as possible.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account