On the Origin of Clockwork, Perpetual Motion Devices, and the CompassPrice, Derek J. de Solla (Derek John de Solla)
History
On the Origin of Clockwork, Perpetual Motion Devices, and the Compass
Price, Derek J. de Solla (Derek John de Solla)
Clocks and watches; Horology
Some technical details can be gleaned however. The shape of the gear
teeth appears to be almost exactly equilateral triangles in all cases
(fig. 8), and square shanks may be seen at the centers of some of the
wheels. No wheel is quite complete enough for a count of gear teeth, but
a provisional reconstruction by Theophanidis (fig. 9) has shown that the
appearances are consistent with the theory that the purpose of the
gears was to provide the correct angular ratios to move the sun and
planets at their appropriate relative speeds.
[Illustration: Figure 8.--ANTIKYTHERA MACHINE, DETAIL FROM FIGURE 6,
showing gearing. (_Photo courtesy of National Museum, Athens._)]
Thus, if the evidence of the Antikythera machine is to be taken at its
face value, we have, already in classical times, the use of astronomical
devices as complicated as any clock. In any case, the material supplied
by the works ascribed to Archimedes, Hero, and Vitruvius, and the more
certain evidence of the anaphoric clocks is sufficient to show that
there was a strong classical tradition of such machines, a tradition
that inspired, even if it did not directly influence, later developments
in Islam and Europe on the one side, and, just possibly, China on the
other.
_Note added in proof_:
Since the above lines were written, I have been privileged
to make a full examination of the fragments in the
National Museum in Athens. As a result we can read much
more inscription and make out many more details of the
mechanism. The cleaning and disentangling of the fragments
by the museum staff has proceeded to the stage where one
can assert much more positively that the device was an
astronomical computer for sidereal, solar, lunar, and
possibly also planetary phenomena. (See my article in the
_Scientific American_, June 1959, vol. 200, No. 6, pp.
60-67.) Relevant to the present study, it must also be
noted at this point that the machine is now shown to be
strongly related to the geared astrolabe of al-Biruni and
thereby the Hellenistic, Islamic, and European
developments are drawn together even more tightly.
Let us now turn our attention to those civilizations which were
intermediaries, geographically and culturally, between Greece and
medieval Europe, and between both of these and China. From India there
are only two references, very closely related and appearing in the best
known astronomical texts in connection with descriptions of the
armillary sphere and celestial globe. These texts are both quite
garbled, but so far as one may understand them, it seems that the types
of spheres and globes mentioned are more akin to those current in China
than in the West. The relevant portions of text are as follows (italics
supplied):
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account