On the phenomena of variation and geographical distribution as illustrated by the Papilionidæ of the Malayan regionWallace, Alfred Russel
Science
On the phenomena of variation and geographical distribution as illustrated by the Papilionidæ of the Malayan region
Wallace, Alfred Russel
Papilionidae -- Malaysia -- Geographical distribution; Papilionidae -- Malaysia -- Variation
2. _Polymorphism or dimorphism._—By this term I understand the
coexistence in the same locality of two or more distinct forms, not
connected by intermediate gradations, and all of which are occasionally
produced from common parents. These distinct forms generally occur in
the female sex only, and the intercrossing of two of these forms does
not generate an intermediate race, but reproduces the same forms in
varying proportions. I believe it will be found that a considerable
number of what have been classed as _varieties_ are really cases of
_polymorphism_. Albinoism and melanism are of this character, as well as
most of those cases in which well-marked varieties occur in company with
the parent species, but without any intermediate forms. Under these
circumstances, if the two forms breed separately, and are never
reproduced from a common parent, they must be considered as distinct
species, contact without intermixture being a good test of specific
difference. On the other hand, intercrossing without producing an
intermediate race is a test of dimorphism. I consider, therefore, that
under any circumstances the term ‘variety’ is wrongly applied to such
cases.
The Malayan Papilionidæ exhibit some very curious instances of
polymorphism, some of which have been recorded as varieties, others as
distinct species; and they all occur in the female sex. _Papilio
Memnon_, L., is one of the most striking, as it exhibits the mixture of
simple variability, local and polymorphic forms, all hitherto classed
under the common title of varieties. The polymorphism is strikingly
exhibited by the females, one set of which resemble the males in form,
with a variable paler colouring; the others have a large spatulate tail
to the hinder wings and a distinct style of colouring, which causes them
closely to resemble _P. Coon_, a species of which the sexes are alike
and inhabiting the same countries, but with which they have no direct
affinity. The tailless females exhibit simple variability, scarcely two
being found exactly alike even in the same locality. The males of the
island of Borneo exhibit constant differences of the under surface, and
may therefore be distinguished as a local form, while the continental
specimens, as a whole, offer such large and constant differences from
those of the islands that I am inclined to separate them as a distinct
species—_P. Androgeus_, Cr. We have here, therefore, distinct species,
local forms, polymorphism, and simple variability, which seem to me to
be distinct phenomena, but which have been hitherto all classed together
as varieties. I may mention that the fact of these distinct forms being
one species is doubly proved. The males, the tailed and tailless
females, have all been bred from a single group of the larvæ, by Messrs.
Payen and Bocarmé, in Java, and I myself captured in Sumatra a male _P.
Memnon_, L., and a tailed female _P. Achates_, Cr., “in copulâ.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account