On the theory of the infinite in modern thought : $b Two introductory studiesJourdain, Eleanor F. (Eleanor Frances)
Philosophy
On the theory of the infinite in modern thought : $b Two introductory studies
Jourdain, Eleanor F. (Eleanor Frances)
Infinite; Knowledge, Theory of; Pragmatism
Leaving aside the French neo-critical School (Renouvier) and the
English School (Spencer)--the first of whom deny the Infinite,
thus acting in opposition to mathematical reasoning, while the
second perpetuate Kant’s error of considering the Infinite, though
thinkable, as unknowable (Dr. Caird has pointed out that this
position is illogical)--we arrive at a moment in history which is
more fruitful in result on the mathematical side, and will, no doubt,
have an effect on metaphysics. For, owing to recent discoveries
in Germany and England, mathematics is now in a position to give
greater support than before to the intuitions of philosophy.
Hitherto, philosophers have been reluctant to allow full value to
the mathematical conceptions of Infinity, and with some justice, as
the notion had not been sufficiently analysed. Philosophers, who
never attempted the analysis, have been inclined to accept certain
contradictions in their conception as inherent in the nature of
Infinity. Within the last twenty-five years Cantor and Dedekind have
cleared up the notion of continuity, and Russell has given greater
precision to the idea, and has applied this reasoning to philosophy.
Present-day metaphysicians seem to be divided into two groups; on
the one side, those who consider in philosophy the value of a theory
of being, and, on the other, those who chiefly consider the value
of a theory of knowledge, _i.e._ the Epistemologists. The first
group, devoting themselves to psychology, evolution, and history,
have no _necessary_ belief in the Infinite. The Epistemologists,
whose work is founded on Kant, discuss the theory of knowledge and
enumerate the conditions of knowledge. Their argument may not touch,
but does not exclude, the notion of the Infinite. The position of
the Epistemologist has been made infinitely more secure by recent
mathematical work. That of the psychologist remains almost untouched.
It is necessary now to examine more closely the mathematical results
to which reference has been made.
In general terms it may be said that mathematics has, as a study,
led immediately from the nature of the subject to the perception
of the Infinite, and to a knowledge of the connection between the
Infinite and the Finite. The simplest form in which the idea can be
put is stated by St. Augustine, who said that numbers considered
individually were finite, but considered as an aggregate were
infinite.[7] Before St. Augustine, and after him down the long
stream of philosophic thought, the theologian and the philosopher
have turned to mathematics for illustrations of the infinitely great
and infinitely little, as developed from the concrete processes of
arithmetic and geometry. The recurring decimal in arithmetic, the
properties of the circle and ellipse in geometry, of the cone in
conic sections, and of the surd in algebra, all touch the problem of
number and space on the side of Infinity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account