Our Nuclear Future: Facts, Dangers and OpportunitiesTeller, Edward
Science
Our Nuclear Future: Facts, Dangers and Opportunities
Teller, Edward
Nuclear energy -- Popular works; Nuclear weapons; Radioactivity -- Physiological effect
At this present rate a lifetime dosage in northern U.S. is only a small
fraction of a roentgen. A rare individual might get several times this
amount. If tests continue at the present rate, radiation levels could
increase by as much as five-fold. However, even in this situation it is
difficult to imagine anyone receiving a lifetime dose of more than five
or ten roentgens from the world-wide fallout. A more reasonable estimate
for the average lifetime dose would be a few roentgens or less.
One might conclude from these figures that there is no danger whatsoever
from the fallout. This conclusion, however, may not be correct.
The danger from such small doses of radiation is not easy to define.
Even the best statistical methods are insufficient. One is looking for
small effects which show up only after millions of cases have been
studied. Animal experiments are extremely difficult to carry out under
these conditions. Direct controlled experience with human beings is, of
course, impossible. As a result, one is forced to draw conclusions from
the effects at higher dose levels, where experimental data have been
obtained.
This may be done in many ways. One way is to assume that the law of
proportionality holds down to the smallest doses. This means that one
roentgen produces one hundredth as many cases of bone cancer and
leukemia as 100 roentgens produce. This law is plausible. It is by no
means proven.
By arguing in this way one finds that for each megaton of fission energy
which escapes from the test site in the world-wide fallout the lives of
approximately four hundred persons would be shortened by leukemia or
bone cancer. Under present conditions of testing, roughly one half of
the fission products are deposited as close-in fallout in and near the
test site. Per megaton of fission energy exploded, therefore, perhaps
200 persons may get leukemia or bone cancer. This figure could actually
be higher, possibly even a thousand persons or more per megaton. It
could also be lower. It could be zero.
It is possible that radiation of less than a certain intensity does not
cause bone cancer or leukemia at all. In the past small doses of
radiation have often been regarded as beneficial. This was not supported
by any scientific evidence. Today many well-informed people believe that
radiation is harmful even in the smallest amounts. This statement has
been repeated in an authoritative manner. Actually there can be little
doubt that radiation hurts the individual cell. But a living being is a
most complex thing. Damage to a small fraction of the cells might be
beneficial to the whole organism. Some experiments on mice seem to show
that exposure to a little radiation increases the life expectancy of the
animals. Scientific truth is firm—when it is complete. The evidence of
what a little radiation will do to a complex animal like a human being
is in an early and uncertain state.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account