Outlines of a Critical Theory of EthicsDewey, John
Philosophy
Outlines of a Critical Theory of Ethics
Dewey, John
Ethics
Says Mill (Op. cit., p. 323), "The happiness which forms
the Utilitarian standard of what is right in conduct is
not the agent's own happiness, but that of all concerned;
as between his own happiness and that of others,
Utilitarianism requires him to be as strictly impartial
as a disinterested and benevolent spectator." And (page
315) the Utilitarian standard is "not the agent's own
greatest happiness, but the greatest amount of happiness
altogether." See also Sidgwick (Op. cit., p. 379), "By
Utilitarianism is here meant the ethical theory, first
distinctly formulated by Bentham, that the conduct which,
under any given circumstances is externally or objectively
right is that which will produce the greatest amount of
happiness _on the whole_; that is, taking into account
all whose happiness is affected by the conduct. It would
tend to clearness if we might call this principle, and the
method based upon it, by some such name as Universalistic
hedonism." As popularly put, the utilitarian standard is
the "greatest happiness of the greatest number." While
in its calculation "each is to count for one and only
one." (_Bentham_). And finally Bain (Emotions and Mill,
p. 303), "Utility is opposed to the selfish theory, for,
as propounded, it always implies the good of society
generally, and the subordination of individual interests to
the general good."
XXI.
Criticism of Utilitarianism.
The utilitarian theory certainly does away entirely with one of the
two main objections to hedonism--its failure to provide a general,
as distinct from a private end. The question which we have to meet,
however, is whether this extension of the end from the individual to
society is consistent with the fundamental principles of hedonism.
_How_ do we get from individual pleasure to the happiness of all?
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account