Outlines of a Critical Theory of EthicsDewey, John
Philosophy
Outlines of a Critical Theory of Ethics
Dewey, John
Ethics
So far we have been discussing the moral ideal in terms of its inner
side--capacity, interest. We shall now discuss it on its outer or
objective side--as 'adjustment to environment' in the phrase made
familiar by the evolutionists. Certain cautions, however, must be noted
in the use of the phrase. We must keep clearly in mind the relativity
of environment to inner capacity; that it exists only as one element of
function. Even a plant must do something more than adjust itself _to_
a fixed environment; it must assert itself _against_ its surroundings,
subordinating them and transforming them into material and nutriment;
and, on the surface of things, it is evident that _transformation_ of
existing circumstances is moral duty rather than mere reproduction of
them. The environment must be plastic to the ends of the agent.
But admitting that environment is made what it is by the powers
and aims of the agent, what sense shall we attribute to the term
adjustment? Not bare conformity to circumstances, nor bare external
reproduction of them, even when circumstances are taken in their proper
moral meaning. The child in the family who simply adjusts himself _to_
his relationships in the family, may be living a moral life only in
outward seeming. The citizen of the state may transgress no laws of
the state, he may punctiliously fulfill every contract, and yet be a
selfish man. True adjustment must consist in _willing_ the maintenance
and development of moral surroundings as _one's own end_. The child
must take the spirit of the family into himself and live out this
spirit according to his special membership in the family. So a soldier
in the army, a friend in a mutual association, etc. Adjustment to
intellectual environment is not mere conformity of ideas to facts. It
is the living assimilation of these facts into one's own intellectual
life, and maintaining and asserting them as _truth_.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account