Now, it is not an arbitrary relation which unites and amalgamates these
two elements in dogma; it is an organic and necessary relation. Go
back for a moment to the origin of religious phenomena, and to the
formation of the first and simplest doctrinal formulas. In presence of
one of the great spectacles of Nature, man, feeling his weakness and
dependence with respect to the mysterious power revealed in it,
trembled with fear and hope. This is primitive religious emotion. But
this emotion necessarily implies, for thought, a relation between the
subject which experiences it and the object that has caused it. Now,
thought, once awakened, will necessarily translate this relation into
an intellectual judgment. Thus, wishing to express this relation, the
believer will exclaim, _e.g._ "God is great!" marking the infinite
disproportion between his being and the universal being which made him
tremble.[1] He obeys the same necessity which makes him ordinarily
express his thought in language. Religious emotion then is transformed
in the mind into the notion of a relation, _i.e._ into an intellectual
notion which becomes the expressive image or representation of the
emotion. But the notion and the emotion are essentially different in
nature. In expressing it, and thanks to the imagination, the notion
may renew or fortify the emotion, and dogma may awaken piety; but the
two must not be confounded. The notion is like an algebraic expression
which ideally represents a given quantity, but it is not the quantity
itself. This must be clearly kept in mind if we are to avoid the most
disastrous confusions. In religion and in dogma the intellectual
element is simply the expression or envelope of the religious
experience....
[1] It might be supposed that I make of this elementary experience the
primary root whence all dogmas, including the Christian, have sprung by
a process of evolution. Nothing of the kind. This is but a particular
example. The revelation of Nature is the principle of the dogmas of
the Religions of Nature. Christianity has behind it another revelation
and other experiences: the revelation of God and of a higher life, in
the historical appearance of Jesus Christ. Let a man morally prepared
to hear the Gospel begin to follow Him, listen to His words, penetrate
His soul, comprehend His death, and he will cry out: "God is Love!" as
the spectator of Nature was supposed to exclaim: "God is great!" And
this new proposition, translating a new religious relation, will, in
its turn, become the principle of all Christian dogmas.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account