Overtones, a book of temperaments : $b Richard Strauss, Parsifal, Verdi, Balzac, Flaubert, Nietzsche, and TurgénieffHuneker, James
Philosophy
Overtones, a book of temperaments : $b Richard Strauss, Parsifal, Verdi, Balzac, Flaubert, Nietzsche, and Turgénieff
Huneker, James
Music
I could not know that my opinion on Sarah Bernhardt would become
public property, and I am very sorry for it. But I am not in the
habit of withdrawing my opinions, even when I have expressed them
in a private and friendly conversation, and they are made public
against my will. Yes, I consider M. A——’s criticism of her quite
true and just. This woman is clever and skilful; she has her
business at her fingers’ ends, is gifted with a charming voice and
educated in a good school; but she has nothing natural about her,
no artistic temperament whatever, and she tries to make up for
this by Parisian license. She is eaten through and through with
_chic_, _réclame_, and pose. She is monotonous, cold, and dry; in
short, without a single spark of talent in the highest sense of
the word. Her gait is that of a hen; she has no play of features;
the movements of her hands are purposely angular in order to be
piquant; the whole thing reeks of the boulevards, of Figaro, and
patchouli. You see that, to my mind, M. A—— has been even too
lenient. You quote Zola as an authority, although you always rebel
against all authorities, so you must allow me to quote Augier, who
once said to me: “Cette femme n’a aucun talent; on dit d’elle que
c’est un paquet de nerfs—c’est un paquet de ficelles.” But, you
will ask, Why then such a world-wide reputation? What do I care?
I only speak my own feelings, and I am glad to find somebody who
supports my view.
But these _ficelles_ are artistic to-day. Doubtless Turgénieff would
have been one of the first to recognize the unassuming realistic
talents of Duse. There is nothing more touching than his adjuration
to Tolstoy to forsake his half-cracked philosophy and return to
literature:—
VERY DEAR LEON NIKOLAIEVITCH: It is a long time since I wrote
to you. I was then, and I am now, on my deathbed. I cannot
recover; there is no longer the least chance of it. I am writing
to you expressly to tell you how happy I have been to be your
contemporary, and to make you a last urgent prayer. My friend,
return to literary work. This gift has come to you from there
whence everything comes to us. Ah! how happy I should be if I could
know that you would listen to my prayer!... My friend, great writer
of our Russian land, hear my prayer. Let me know if this letter
reaches you. I clasp you for the last time to my heart—you and all
yours.... I can write no more.... I am tired.
Tolstoy, on his side, could never understand Turgénieff’s fear of
death. He said:—
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account