33. R. H. Charles, _A Critical History of the Doctrine of a Future Life in Israel, in Judaism, and in Christianity_, London, 1899, is a convenient book, but one which must be used with caution. 34. A. Harnack, _Lehrbuch der Dogmengeschichte_, i, 4th ed., 1909; English translation from the third German edition, 1901; G. B. Stevens, _The Theology of the New Testament_, 1903; H. Holtzmann, _Lehrbuch der neutestamentlichen Theologie_, 2 vols., 2d ed., 1911. 35. _Rep._, ii, 363 D. 36. _Apol._, 41. 37. It should be said that even in the earliest period Christian baptism had certain magical notions attached to it; not, however, the belief that it secured immortality. 38. Cf. Hatch, _The Influence of Greek Ideas and Usages on the Christian Church_, X, B; Anrich, _Das antike Mysterienwesen in seinem Einfluss auf das Christentum_, 1894, pp. 168 ff., especially 179 ff. 39. _Hom. in Num._, xxv; _in Ps._ xxxvi, 3. 40. _C. D._, xx, 25; xxi, 13 (where Virgil’s verses given above are quoted), 26; _de octo Dulcitii Quaest._, _Qu._ i, 13; _Enchiridion_, lxix. 41. St. Thomas, _Opera_ (Venice, 1759), xii, p. 575, _Distinctio_ xxi, _Quaes._ 1, _Sol._ 3; xiii, p. 347 ff., _Distinctio_ xliv, _Quaes._ 3, _Art._ 4, _Quaestiunc._ 3; Bellarmino, _de Purgatorio_, II, x-xii. End of the Project Gutenberg EBook of Pagan Ideas of Immortality During the Early Roman Empire, by Clifford Herschel Moore