Papers and Proceedings of the Twenty-Third General Meeting of the American Library Association: Held at Waukesha, Wisconsin, July 4-10, 1901
Science
Papers and Proceedings of the Twenty-Third General Meeting of the American Library Association: Held at Waukesha, Wisconsin, July 4-10, 1901
American Library Association; Library science -- Congresses
Miss KROEGER: I have been teaching in the library school according to A.
L. A. measurements, yet it has always seemed to me somewhat absurd. None
of the publishers have adopted it; I suppose the newer libraries have.
The replies received to the questions sent to the various libraries
last June, except for the newer libraries, indicate that the majority
are using the fold symbol, and they would like to know why, if the
letter symbol is such a good thing, the publishers are still marking
their books 8vo, 12mo and 4to. The fold symbol means more to the mass of
the people than do the letters O or D.
Mr. BOWKER: If I remember correctly the London _Bookseller_ is giving
the exact size and measurement now.
Mr. HARRIS: Many literary and critical journals give the size of all
books recorded in inches.
Mr. BOWKER: The Publishing Board is extremely interested in getting the
feeling of those here on the question. I want to suggest that when it
comes to the rising vote or show of hands, we take a somewhat
complicated vote: those who are in favor of the present A. L. A. letter;
those in favor of returning to the fold (I mean not in the usual sense);
those in favor of exact measurement in centimeters; those in favor of a
combination of letter symbol and centimeter; and those in favor of the
fold symbol and centimeter. The board wants all the information it can
get.
CHAIRMAN: I will ask Mr. Bowker to state the first proposition.
Mr. BOWKER: Those in favor of the letter symbol, the present A. L. A.
method, please rise. Twenty-four rose.
Mr. BOWKER: Those in favor of returning to the fold symbol, the 8vo,
12mo and 4to please rise. Ten rose.
Mr. BOWKER: Those who prefer a designation of actual measurement, please
rise--with the understanding that those voting for this will then vote
their preference as to either inches or centimeters. Seventeen rose.
CHAIRMAN: Your next proposition, Mr. Bowker.
Mr. BOWKER: Those who would prefer centimeters if exact measurement
should be adopted, please rise. Thirty-two rose.
Mr. BOWKER: Now those who would prefer inches if an exact measurement
were adopted. Three rose.
CHAIRMAN: As many as are in favor of the exact measurement coupled with
the A. L. A. symbol, in case there is to be a combination--letter and
exact size--please rise. Thirty-two rose.
CHAIRMAN: Now those who would prefer the combination of exact size with
figure symbol. Sixteen rose.
Mr. JOSEPHSON: We might have another vote on whether the size should
mean letterpress or book.
CHAIRMAN: Before this is done I want to call attention to the effect of
binding after cataloging. If this scheme is going to take in foreign
books, and you are going to get cards promptly, a large share of the
books will be cataloged before they are bound. If a good binder does his
work conscientiously and as it should be done, if you give the page you
will have a more satisfactory measurement.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account